I would use "childish" and "tacky" ahead of "anodyne".
It really isn't that interesting imo - hence anodyne.
I don't see it as either childish or tacky - just a bit predictable given the home shirt.
The only issue I have with it - beyond it being a bit uninteresting - is that it's blue and I have never seen that as a Tigers colour.
Gimme the ring, kissed and toll'd
Gimme something that I missed (gimme the ring)
A hand to hold, wild and what it seems(gimme the ring)
Kill the king, when love is the law,
And the we'll turn round... (gimme the ring)