Bath comprehensively beat Northampton to set up semi-final
BathRugbyEre.co.uk
(IP Logged)
28 January, 2012 18:50
What do you think? You can have your say by posting below.
If you do not already have an account Click here to Register.
Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 02/02/2012 19:25 by Glen The Ed.
If you do not already have an account Click here to Register.
Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 02/02/2012 19:25 by Glen The Ed.
Re: Bath comprehensively beat Northampton to set up semi-final
Susanne
(IP Logged)
28 January, 2012 19:09
Thanks Nicola - great report of a fun game.
Anyone think Biggsy was tripped when he gathered the penalty that rebounded from the post? Thought it looked more like a trip than a tap tackle.
And anyone know where we can see Perenise's try again? That's one I want to save as a favourite on YouTube and watch again and again. Especially as it seemed to take him by surprise - just getting up from being at the bottom of a ruck and finding the ball bobbling in front of him.
Proud to adopt one of our stars of the future
Anyone think Biggsy was tripped when he gathered the penalty that rebounded from the post? Thought it looked more like a trip than a tap tackle.
And anyone know where we can see Perenise's try again? That's one I want to save as a favourite on YouTube and watch again and again. Especially as it seemed to take him by surprise - just getting up from being at the bottom of a ruck and finding the ball bobbling in front of him.
Proud to adopt one of our stars of the future
Re: Bath comprehensively beat Northampton to set up semi-final
P G Tips
(IP Logged)
28 January, 2012 20:25
Yes Susanne - it looked that way to me, both live & on TV replay. Can anybody else confirm?
PG
PG
Re: Bath comprehensively beat Northampton to set up semi-final
Hamptonite
(IP Logged)
28 January, 2012 20:29
Yes, Susanne, it happened in front of us and it was definitely a trip. Not sure how the referee or assistants could not award a penalty!
I wanted to watch both that and the Perenise try, but my Sky recording failed! Only blot on a decent day!
I wanted to watch both that and the Perenise try, but my Sky recording failed! Only blot on a decent day!
Re: Bath comprehensively beat Northampton to set up semi-final
TallRugbyGirl
(IP Logged)
28 January, 2012 21:00
video: [url]
[/url]
[/url]
Re: Bath comprehensively beat Northampton to set up semi-final
OLoingseach
(IP Logged)
28 January, 2012 21:01
Go to Rugbydump.com to see Perenise's try. Watched it several times 
Re: Bath comprehensively beat Northampton to set up semi-final
Susanne
(IP Logged)
28 January, 2012 22:17
Thanks TRG - I could watch that all night!
Can a trip be cited?
Proud to adopt one of our stars of the future
Can a trip be cited?
Proud to adopt one of our stars of the future
Re: Bath comprehensively beat Northampton to set up semi-final
retired
(IP Logged)
29 January, 2012 13:22
Suzanne
I thought it was a trip at the time and I believe they can be cited as an act of foul or illegal play, the litmus test is “would the action have received a red card”
I thought it was a trip at the time and I believe they can be cited as an act of foul or illegal play, the litmus test is “would the action have received a red card”
Re: Bath comprehensively beat Northampton to set up semi-final
P G Tips
(IP Logged)
29 January, 2012 13:59
Should have done OEC - but don't hold your breath.
I have seen a few at the Rec in recent seasons which have not been picked up on the day, or by citing.
It seems accepted as part of the game now, which I think is plain wrong.
PG
I have seen a few at the Rec in recent seasons which have not been picked up on the day, or by citing.
It seems accepted as part of the game now, which I think is plain wrong.
PG
Re: Bath comprehensively beat Northampton to set up semi-final
Tall Paul
(IP Logged)
29 January, 2012 20:25
I thought a trip was a yellow card? In which case very little point awarding one after the game. I guess it may vary depending on position on the pitch and likely outcome if there was no trip, i.e. if Biggs would DEFINATELY have scored it may be worth citing. I can't remember specifically but I seem to remember there being other defenders around Tom so doubt they would cite it now.
Michael van Vuuren- adopted player 2016-17
Michael van Vuuren- adopted player 2016-17
Re: Bath comprehensively beat Northampton to set up semi-final
TCM2007
(IP Logged)
29 January, 2012 21:40
Quote:(d) Tripping. A player must not trip an opponent with the leg or foot. Sanction: Penalty kick
Laws just say penalty
Stuart
Former ed.
Re: Bath comprehensively beat Northampton to set up semi-final
CoochieCoo
(IP Logged)
29 January, 2012 21:58
It was a penalty offence and as it was almost 5 metres out from the try line it was a red zone offence and should have been yellow.
Re: Bath comprehensively beat Northampton to set up semi-final
Blocks2u
(IP Logged)
29 January, 2012 22:45
Thanks for the report Nicola, excellent.
Managed to get some pictures from my perch here....
[picasaweb.google.com]
Not confident about the link working google seem to have reconfigured the process.
Ian
Managed to get some pictures from my perch here....
[picasaweb.google.com]
Not confident about the link working google seem to have reconfigured the process.
Ian
Re: Bath comprehensively beat Northampton to set up semi-final
Patrick
(IP Logged)
31 January, 2012 14:22
Re: Bath comprehensively beat Northampton to set up semi-final
gaz909
(IP Logged)
31 January, 2012 14:51
crackin photos (as always patrick), didn't realise that perenise's try involved a neat bit of juggling
thats a good one also at top of thread, not difficult to see why he's called 'beaver'
thats a good one also at top of thread, not difficult to see why he's called 'beaver'
Sorry, you do not have permission to post/reply in this forum.
