Rumour has it that Matt Carraro is going to Montpellier. Just hope it is just a rumour !!!



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 22/02/2012 22:19 by Bluesboy7.

He's got a year to run on his contract hasn't he?

---

Stuart

Former ed.

Can we park that with Ryan Caldwell to Leinster rumour.

Hope both of these are just rumours!

Go Matt, go!

---

If you do not have a celery cap buying out contracts is not an issue !!

Wilson to Newcastle

Biggs to Leeds

Banahan to Leicester

---

Bod to New Zealand

---

Stuart

Former ed.

Looks like Steve and I have found the source of the tale...

Taken from twitter...

Malcolm Cupis@BlokeInBath
Matt Carraro was in Montpellier finalising a contract offer today. Shame, one of my favourite Bath backs. Greatly under-rated.

26m Stuart Moss@StuartMMoss
@BlokeInBath but he only signed a new deal 12 months ago... Could have sworn it was for more than 1 year...?

24m Malcolm Cupis@BlokeInBath
@StuartMMoss 1year plus option.

17m Stuart Moss@StuartMMoss
@BlokeInBath not according to here [news.bbc.co.uk] says staying until end of 2012-13 season... Hope you are wrong this time! :-)

14m Malcolm Cupis@BlokeInBath
@StuartMMoss Sad to say he spent the day with Montpellier today.

5m Stuart Moss@StuartMMoss
@BlokeInBath seems odd esp with contract & lack of other gossip from French sites... You have proof? Not fighting, just asking! :-)

Malcolm Cupis@BlokeInBath
@StuartMMoss I have a spy...in Montpellier.

Stuart Moss@StuartMMoss
@BlokeInBath that old chestnut... :-) Hmmm believe it when I see it! As I said, not fighting, just doubting! :-)

Malcolm Cupis@BlokeInBath
@StuartMMoss Being a little more specific, this spy is in the club, not just the city. They made him an offer a month ago.

Read into that what you want...not sure how accurate or reliable this 'spy' is??

We're re-signing Tinds eh? Sounds about right!

---

I know Malco has some good connections in France.

He was au fait with Simon Taylor's signing and Jacques Boussuge. Therefore I am extremely confident that he will be right.

Quote:

TCM2007
Bod to New Zealand

Sim to Melksham and Bath girls development

If we lose Matt I'll be incredibly unhappy. He has been brilliant and has been one of the most underrated centres in the premiership, we'll really struggle to find an adequate replacement. Please lord can it not be true!

Not sure he is underated, under played maybe - perhaps that's the problem.

Wiping the place clean of all things "Smee" - great ambition and vision!

---

Can't believe it,is this true or not?

If true it is solid proof that Grandad has lost his marbles - pah!

---

Quote:

Ex-Bod
If true it is solid proof that Grandad has lost his marbles - pah!

Did you need any more proof Bod ?

Under played is so true.

he is the best outside centre we have, I just wish he was played more.

I don't like this blatant vandalism. Hipkiss over Cararro?

---

Will be an absolute disaster becasue at last I understand Carraro is UK qualified by residence nearly and he is not a 'foreign' player.

Like many others I believe he deserves a proper run in the first team as he has never let us down, tackles like a train, CAN PASS, and has real speed especially over the first 10 meters. He is and has been IMHO the best centre consistently playing for the club and best 13 by far!

I could think of one or two others I would like to see go before Matt C!

Quote:

Bathovalballer
Will be an absolute disaster becasue at last I understand Carraro is UK qualified by residence nearly and he is not a 'foreign' player.
Like many others I believe he deserves a proper run in the first team as he has never let us down, tackles like a train, CAN PASS, and has real speed especially over the first 10 meters. He is and has been IMHO the best centre consistently playing for the club and best 13 by far!

I could think of one or two others I would like to see go before Matt C!

Totally agree BOB. No comparison between him and Banners @13

Also agree with BoB,I don't believe it,we would be mad to let him go but he has been messed about.

Can anyone confirm this rumour/ story? Where is Marshie 10 wheh we want him?

So, as we aren't going to sign any outside backs apparently, we're going to get the same but without the best 13. Oh joy!

As I understand it we're bringing back both Maggs and Tinds for their passing abilities. Biggs and woodburn will be sold into slavery as we will have no need of a winger. Bendy is off to Bhutan to rediscover the meaning of life.

Seriously, the above reaction to the possibility of Matt's departure just highlights one of my main problems with current recruitment. Matt is a fine player, reliable, dependable and rock solid, and he can pass. However he is not international class, and theres the rub. We need a midfield spark. He's the best we've got, which sums up how I rate those who are keeping him out of the team. Our midfield is slow, ponderous and predictable. It is a wonder that the wingers ever score, so suggests that they are really a cut above.

I do't know who I'd like to sign, because to be frank all the intelligent centres are foreign it seems. an influx of taffs perhaps?

Whilst I understand your point a bit Ade it seems a bit odd.

You acknowledge that he is the best that we have got but then don't have a problem with getting rid of him? Surely if he's the best centre the club have he should be retained and the worst centre we have should be released!?

From the Chronicle article about us not signing Gethin, Ade; Blofeld said Bath were “not actively” looking for an additional outside back for next season. So the spark has to come from those already there.

With us not signing Gethin (£250k) , if this rumour is true about Carraro (£120k salary?) then this frees up a huge amount of cash to sign someone.

Get on the phone to Tongahui'ha.

This would be really bad news if it turns out to be true. Matt has always really stood out whenever he's played, either at centre or wing. He's got pace, strength and a good rugby brain - we should be pulling out all the stops to keep him & discourage the CESMs.

Stay at Bath please Matt - you know it makes sense!

Unlike the other rumours, I wouldn't be surprised if this had some legs to it.
Malco does have his contacts and even with a year left on his contract the club may consider him surplus to requirements. It would appear that way as he always struggles to get a game even when we don't have 2 Kolpak players and I'd want to leave if I was being kept out of 13 by an at best; off form player and at worst; a bad outside centre (I'll let you pick which).

I'll get upset when it happens, and when it does we'll I'll think about the two other OCs we have and probably survive.

Is he qualifying as European next year? I guess that would be a reason to keep him, but also a reason why his stock goes up.

Barters, I would be sorry to see Matt go, at the moment, as he is our best centre. In the longterm however we need to improve our options so that someone of his calibre would be at best on the bench. [I may be doing him a disservice here, as I know we can't have top rank players in every position, but having grown up in the days of J guscott I have a soft spot for a searingly scintillating 13]. So what I am saying is: if we wish to have any chance of winning the AP or the HC, then we need to totally reassess our centre options.

DBF, I realise that the management puts no importance on outside back improvements. I don't agree, as I think is clear from the above. For all the cries for the likes of Barkley and Banahan to be in the England team, it is just rose tinteds I feel. OB was excellent outside Butch James, but failed to deliver without. Banahan is not an international class anything. Quite where to play him is a conundrum, but if I wanted another forward as a 13, I'd pick Louw or Taylor.

Well, there's very little point in having a great sports car in the garage if the only car you take out and drive is your Golf.

How Banahan, Hipkiss, or Barclay can be picked ahead of Carraro when all fit is a mystery - Cararro with Williams would be first choice centres with Donald at 10.
Banahan isn't a centre in the first place and why SIM continues to try and fix him into midfield is bizarre.

I'm sure Matt will have more fun outside Trin-Duc

---

Quote:

Ex-Bod
Wiping the place clean of all things "Smee" - great ambition and vision!

He signed his last contract under SIM.

---

Stuart

Former ed.

Think I'll burn my season ticket now.

Quote:

Ex-Bod
How Banahan, Hipkiss, or Barclay can be picked ahead of Carraro when all fit is a mystery - Cararro with Williams would be first choice centres with Donald at 10.
Banahan isn't a centre in the first place and why SIM continues to try and fix him into midfield is bizarre.

How you can spell Barkley wrong when he's been a prominent member of the Bath side for 11 of the past 12 years is the real mystery.

And if we're talking about where Banahan was 'in the first place' he'd never have played on the wing at all.

I am wrong to think that this rumour will fade away like the others? Anyone got the evidence to quash it! Please...
Please...
Please...

Best evidence we've got is that he's under contract, and doesn't seem the type to walk away from that.

However, we've recently been burned by Butch walking away from a contract, and Malco does have a history of getting the scoops.

---

A man who cannot change his mind, cannot change anything
RAEBURN SHIELD


Beno Obano - 2016-17 adoptee

Sorry SZ - pidling little hand held - no excuse!
I think Banners could now achieve more back in the forwards.

---

It may be too late for that now Bod, but I also think he'd be better suited at 6 or 8.

Are there many/any players who have starting caps for England as a back and a forward?

---

Neil Back Bod

---

Have you found the Black Rat?? I have!!

Thanks mabr!

---

mabr: think you and Bod have the makings of a double act there!

Moving on, Saints are rumoured to be after Jonathan Davies. I wouldn't mind losing MC if we signed someone of that calibre. Perhaps D-Day could put in a good word.

For what it's worth I am now 99% sure that Malcolm is correct and Matt Carraro is off to Montpellier.

I have heard that it is very much the club not taking an option in his contract rather than Matt wanting to leave...

I would never run the club down but this is a big mistake.

Quote:

Barters
I have heard that it is very much the club not taking an option in his contract rather than Matt wanting to leave...

If they're not bringing in any outside backs that's incredibly short-sighted based just on squad cover without even considering his relative performances. Perhaps we're going to see more of Vesty and Cuthbert next season



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 23/02/2012 16:33 by devizes bath fan.