Bri we need a proper captain who does not have to be popular but someone who the troops would follow into the trenches and play their hearts out for and put their bodies on the line to ensure victory!
I would give it to Attwood who appears to care and shout at the others! He is the best I have seen in this bunch! You and Marshie might know different!
To your first point, I think for the troops to follow someone into the trenches, the captain would firstly have to be popular, and secondly this would only happen at a paintballing arena.
To your second point, you may not have seen, but I would also have Attwood as captain, or Fearns.