Sorry Mr Tub, I've got to bite on this one.
He was promoted at Gloucester as the easy option & as you say inherited a very good side that needed a fresh voice. But lets not pretend it was going swimmingly when he got the job or that they won anything. in fact, 6 defeats in a row saw them finish 9th
Redpath is made DOR at Sale June 2012 & replaced by Dimes in October 2012. He was a lame duck for the rest of his time at the club. Also, look at how their backline has improved since his departure.
Carnegie are 2nd, yes, 8 behind London Irish, but 19 ahead of Doncaster in third. Are you trying to tell me the Championship is competitive? Yorkshire has more money than most, more facilities than most, certainly in comparison to say Bedford.
Looks like failure to me.
The calls for Jim's head? From a handful of posters on here who won't listen to reason & the press who are looking for a story. Why get upset with them when it's so much easier to ignore them? Most people have worked where the Saints problems lay.