Latest News:

The Good, The Bad and The Ugly: Season Review

Blackadder: execute plan

By P G Tips
May 9 2017

So, Saturday’s fairy tale happy ending did not materialise. Tigers wrapped up a Playoff place at Sixways, while Bath failed to win at Sale, letting slip the slim chance to make the Top 4. What then, to make of Todd Blackadder’s first season? Beginning with hope, joy and expectation, it soon developed as many plot twists and improbable characters as a spaghetti western. For me, it was a case of “The Good, The Bad and The Ugly”.     

The Good

  •       European Qualification
    At least we got that- the minimum expectation of a club with Bath’s ambition, squad and facilities. Despite some late season angst it was not really in doubt but the seeding will make for some tough ties in 2017-18.
  •       Strength in Depth
    After the short sightedly restrictive selection policy of the previous coaching regime, Todd’s willingness to trust the whole squad was refreshing. Of course, some brave selections were enforced by injury, but so many stepped up to show what they can do that sensible rotation is now a real possibility for next season. Perhaps more significantly, there should be no reason for ambitious but frustrated talents to seek greener pastures as Fearns, Woodburn and Devoto did in the past two seasons.
  •       Emerging Talent
    See above. Ellis, Mercer, Dunn and (to slightly lesser extent) Clark have been a revelation. Eddie Jones has certainly noted the three forwards. Add to these the impressive development of Ewels, signing of Underhill and potential of Jack Walker – Bath have found a rich seam of precious young mettle (spelling deliberate).
  •       Unity
    Unsettling departure and recent rumour notwithstanding, this year’s seems a happier squad, newcomers have integrated well and there is a clear game plan.
  •       DisciplinThe yellow card blight of last season was banished and the penalty count much reduced. It is hard to play winning rugby on the wrong side of the Ref – however wrong the ref may be in the first place (another topic entirely, down to the confused lack of synergy in modern rugby law making).


The Bad


  • League Position
    5th may be better than some feared after last year’s debacle, but after the first third of AP games Bath were 2nd. It is the manner of missing out that hurts and disappoints: all the final four fixtures were winnable, yet it was the notionally tougher ones that Bath won while the “easier” two opponents found the motivation, form and dynamism to restrict Bath to a single league point. The result is we are “Second best of the second best” trailing Leicester by 5 points, but the leading 3 by 18 or more.
  • Declining performance
    A real concern. Only one defeat in the opening seven fixtures, followed by the second and final thirds of the season where more were lost than won. A flourish at the end has become expected at Bath, even in poorer years and this year’s lame ending was as deflating as the opening games were encouraging.
  • Away Form
    This one vies with the decline as the worst aspect. Again it is not so much losing away as how defeat is snatched from the jaws of victory. Early season signs were good: a first win at Northampton in 16 seasons, patiently battling to a dramatic triumph at Exeter and an injury ravaged team sticking it to Gloucester in the last 10 minutes all brought smiles to supporters faces. These are not easy places for the visitor, so subsequent failure at Newcastle, Bristol, Worcester and Sale became all the more galling as a result.
  • Decision Making
    Too often deserted the team’s leaders at key moments. Was it the co-captain thing or confidence problems at 10? Too many leads squandered. A big improvement needed next year.
  • Bristol
    Beaten by a team staring relegation in the face. Bested at the breakdown, missed an easy penalty and allowed Gavin Henson to dictate the play and result. Nuff said!


The Ugly


  • Ford Factor
    Not an anti George rant-I have been an admirer of his talent and play since his Leicester debut aged 17. He stands comparison with Bath’s other creative fly halves: Barnes, Catt, James. He may well outdo all of them on the international stage. His future has this season been a distraction – at times for him, for the squad and the fans. It seems there is still a negative legacy from his father’s era as coach. We as fans now seek a messiah, risking unreasonable expectations on his successor. Time to move on.
  • Challenge Cup Semi
    Nine sublime minutes put Bath in charge. Fitter than their opponents they simply needed to play the percentages deep in opposition territory. Instead, four minutes of madness and a winnable final was surrendered.
  • Kicking Strategy
    Not the strategy itself, but poorly executed. A main factor in away defeats to Newcastle & Stade and at home to Exeter. To work it needs good chase follow-up, stern defence and most of all, accuracy. And against weak, under –confident attack what is wrong with forcing a lineout deep in the opposition 22 to force turnovers with press defence?
  • Defence
    Again, not the system – second best in the league and real improvement on last season– but the slips at crucial times –especially Exeter at home and Stade.
  • Injuries
    Not in “The Bad” list, as it must not be an excuse, but not since 2004, when 10 different players were pressed into service at full back has one position been so plundered – 7 hookers in a single year. With the range of other injuries suffered, it is no wonder that performance was so inconsistent. We hope for better luck from September.


The hope for next season? An injury free pre season and quick start; swift integration of Freddie Burns; continued development of the club’s young talent and better execution of the Blackadder “cunning plan” in attack.


View a Printer Friendly version of this Story.

Bookmark or share this story with: (IP Logged)

The Good, The Bad and The Ugly: Season Review
09/05/2017 08:34
What do you think? You can have your say by posting below.
If you do not already have an account Click here to Register.

Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2017:05:22:14:47:44 by hasta.

hasta (IP Logged)

Re: The Good, The Bad and The Ugly: Season Review
09/05/2017 09:21
Great summary PG Tips! Hard to disagree with that.

gaz59 (IP Logged)

Re: The Good, The Bad and The Ugly: Season Review
09/05/2017 11:05
Excellent, thank you

john fox
johnnyf (IP Logged)

Re: The Good, The Bad and The Ugly: Season Review
09/05/2017 17:35
Can't disagree with the previous comments.
It's been a season that is hard to put into words but this does it.

Team Blackadder have had a testing baptism to the Premiership but they should be all the richer for that next time around.

Bathovalballer (IP Logged)

Re: The Good, The Bad and The Ugly: Season Review
09/05/2017 20:08
Really good analysis of our curates egg of a season, and I agree with most of your observations.

It is all down to the guys on the pitch, not the coaches who give them the bullets to fire, the players have to fire the guns. If the players have as we are often told, 'learned from the experiences and the defeats', we should see much improvement next time around. However, after recent events, I remain to be convinced they have it in them , both physically and more importantly, mentally. Lets hope they can rise above the mediocrity, but I doubt it.

IMO one huge improvement would be the appointment of a top player as ONE on field club captain, one who is both respected, feared and leads by example. In many ways, I would like it to be Kahn but Atters would be a very good second choice.

P G Tips
P G Tips (IP Logged)

Re: The Good, The Bad and The Ugly: Season Review
09/05/2017 20:27
I agree with the final sentiment BoB - but am not entirely sure about Khan.

No slight on him as a player, but 9s lead on the pitch anyway. For every successful SH leader (& there have been many) there is one who find Captaincy, as opposed to game management, a burden.

Agree about Attwood. Garvey would be a fine deputy. It is no coincidence IMHO that the absence of the two saw our performances decline.


B4thB4ck (IP Logged)

Re: The Good, The Bad and The Ugly: Season Review
10/05/2017 07:33
We often hope that players and coaches don't read this forum but I would be happy for them to read this review.

BathMatt53 (IP Logged)

Re: The Good, The Bad and The Ugly: Season Review
10/05/2017 08:20
To be fair, if there is anything in the review that the coaches didn't know then I would be worried!

Fair assessment PG. Only things that I would flag are that, in relation to the start of the season we had an 'easy' start in comparative terms so being second was just as much of a reflection on that. Wasn't the Exeter loss partly down to a loss of front row - Stade was just down to bad judgement and tackling at the death...

Bath Supporter Jack

Re: The Good, The Bad and The Ugly: Season Review
12/05/2017 09:22
Yes reading that was cathartic as it hit the nail on the head.

I physically have my new season tickets already so I'm all set for 2017/18.........oh b******* I've now got to wait nearly four months!

Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.
We record all IP addresses on the Sportnetwork message boards which may be required by the authorities in case of defamatory or abusive comment. We seek to monitor the Message Boards at regular intervals. We do not associate Sportnetwork with any of the comments and do not take responsibility for any statements or opinions expressed on the Message Boards. If you have any cause for concern over any material posted here please let us know as soon as possible by e-mailing

Bath Poll

What sort of pitch would you prefer in our new stadium?

See results > Submit >>