Username
Password
Reality check

MOTM
By Leipziger
November 28 2009
Northampton survived a tight first half before dominating and pulling away from the Falcons after the break, as Lee Dickson and Phil Dowson returned to KP and helped the Saints to a first win in the North East since 2006.

After an encouraging first half ended 8-8, the away pack took apart our eight in the second 40 to set the foundation for a further two tries that left us contemplating a 20-point defeat and whether, just maybe, talk of fourth place in the Premiership may have been slightly premature.


Steve Bates made only one change to the team that won in Reading, with Alex Tait being the one replaced by Tom Biggs and Charlie Amesbury moving to full-back, although Matt Thompson made a return to the bench for the first time in a while. Bruce Reihana was a late withdrawal for the Saints, captained by England's Dylan Hartley.


Northampton got the scoreboard ticking early on when Dowson went for the line but the game was brought back inside for a penalty under the posts, and Shane Geraghty, who had a great game I thought, tapping to help set up Chris Ashton all alone on the right. The conversion went wide, and Jimmy Gopperth and Geraghty exchanged penalties to keep the deficit at five points.


Coming towards the half hour, Northampton conceded three quick penalties in their 22 but controversial referee Greg Garner refused to give either a penalty try or a yellow card, I can only imagine because perhaps they were for different offences, and each time Gopperth kicked for the corner and we drove from the lineout.


The decision to play was proven correct when James Hudson and Tane Tu'ipulotu stretched the Saints defence on the left and allowed Biggs to easily score his first league try for the Falcons in the corner to level the scores, as the conversion did not go over.


Going into half-time 8-8 we had to be encouraged as Amesbury had almost scored on the right too, and we were coping well with something we had not seen too many times this season – an opposition genuinely looking to play rugby and also being good at it.


As with our two home draws this season though, something happened or didn't happen at half-time and Newcastle came out of the dressing room a different team, one that was almost completely dominated for the first half an hour of the second period. I think the only time we got into the away 22 in that time was a run on the left by Amesbury, who tried to chip over the defence but succeeded only in finding Ben Foden who inevitably claimed a mark.


Ashton scored an excellent second try from the 22, steaming across the defence towards the right, and Geraghty converted to take his team seven points ahead. Our cause wasn't helped by Micky Young being sin-binned for an innocuous offence on the 22, but the penalty was successfully kicked over, as was another soon after to probably take Saints out of reach.


Finally starting to play when Young returned to the pitch with ten minutes left, the Falcons made it towards the 22 but replacement Gcobani Bobo dropped the ball under pressure from a tackler with his first touch. Nothing came of our short spell of pressure, and Northampton cleared from a ruck under which Young was injured, and eventually taken off on a stretcher. I presume that was him in the ambulance that went past us after the game with the lights flashing, get well Micky!


After a long stoppage with just 37 seconds on the clock, Geraghty sent a booming kick over to Ashton on the right who completed his hat-trick, and the conversion secured Saints' 8-28 victory.


Strangely I'm not as depressed as I was after the last two home games (yes, less than after the Worcester win). The referee's use and non-use of his cards and his decisions at the breakdown, particularly in the second half, were a little weird but the fact is that our forwards were poor in the second half and did not play the referee properly, while the backs looked completely lacking in ideas when they did get the ball, often just playing a predictable and flat passing line or, less often than before to be fair, kicking and ambling.


Northampton's first and third tries showed up the problem with how narrow we tend to play in attack, as it seems to have led to something similar in defence and so the last man is on his own and scores unchallenged. Lee Dickson may still like his box kicks a bit too much, but his service was for the most part quicker than Young's and to be honest he was a lot more streetwise than our future England 9.


That's always helped by a dominant front row and quick back row though.


Anyway, at least we are reminded now that this team is still a work in progress and that sixth place in the Premiership would still be a good achievement. Not the end in itself of course, but at least a sign that the end is in sight and a possibility.


Until then, we just need to find out how to play for 80 minutes like at Bath more regularly, or at least compete better for the whole game, as at Irish. With Gloucester's form, there is still hope for next week.

View a Printer Friendly version of this Story.

Bookmark or share this story with:

Reality check
Posted by: FalconsRugby.org.uk (IP Logged)
Date: 28/11/2009 10:10

What do you think? You can have your say by posting below.
If you do not already have an account Click here to Register.

Re: Reality check
Posted by: Falconfan (IP Logged)
Date: 28/11/2009 11:57

Good review - sums it up nicely. Beaten by a better team in
the second half. First time this season I've seen our pack
out-muscled. Maybe Carl shouldn't have worn a scrum cap! ( first time I've ever seen him wear one).

Mickey did not have his happiest night at KP; some of his passing was way off, especially that 'could have been fatal' pass inside the 22 which went way over the receiver's head. Jimmy was constantly having to jump to take the pass from the base of the scrum. Dickson did look the better No9 last night.

Re: Reality check
Posted by: Get Stuck In (IP Logged)
Date: 28/11/2009 14:06

Yes, excellent report.
`Reality check' has been the commonest reaction from Falcons fans this morning, although Northampton are a much under-rated outfit.
I do think the shorter recovery time we had after our last game played a part, and would account for our second-half fade-out.
I think Mickey Young was part-unlucky, and part trying too hard because he was lined-up against Lee Dickson who gave him a lesson in quick ball handling.
I still think our backs lack flair. They are tough and determined, but I'm still missing that little bit of class we used to get with Matthew Tait or Toby Flood.

Re: Reality check
Posted by: Dr. B. (IP Logged)
Date: 28/11/2009 14:13

Flood was a very different 10 to Gopperth: he likes to go into contact from time to time and offload before the ball hits the ground - we could do with some more dynamism from Gopperth if we're to really compete against the big boys.

Having said that, I was really disappointed with the backs as a unit last night. Amesbury was the only one (with the possible exception of Biggs) who looked anything like up for it - secure as you like under the high ball and composed. We still miss a general in the backline a la Burkey though.

Re: Reality check
Posted by: Monkey1 (IP Logged)
Date: 28/11/2009 16:17

Good & honest report Leipy, sums it up nicely. The second half was just awful, they seemed to have no stuffing left to knock out of them, body language said it all. The first half however gives me hope, if they can sort themselves out to play like that for the full 80 then they will be right up there with the big boys.

Re: Reality check
Posted by: DGNTR (IP Logged)
Date: 29/11/2009 01:01

"still missing that little bit of class we used to get with Matthew Tait"

"Little bit" being the key words.

I don't miss him at all, I'm happier with Vickerman.

Re: Reality check
Posted by: Falconski (IP Logged)
Date: 29/11/2009 01:45

Shorter recovery time was a factor dont think the lads got chance to prep as much as usual compared to normal games.

Me and lads spoke to a couple of players after the game in bar in west stand and consensus was they didnt have the prep time they usually get.

Re: Reality check
Posted by: falcon phil (IP Logged)
Date: 29/11/2009 09:03

Sorry Falconski I don't buy lack of preparation! its not as if we were asking the guys to do anything different from the Oirish game, they just were much quicker at the break down & hit the rucks much harder. Better at the basics!

Re: Reality check
Posted by: Silvergiraffes (IP Logged)
Date: 29/11/2009 13:30

Our second half performances are a worry though. This is not the first time we have had a good first half only to waste it by not turning up for the second. I would love to know the coaches thoughts on this. Are we simply not fit enough as a team?

Re: Reality check
Posted by: DGNTR (IP Logged)
Date: 29/11/2009 20:43

Prep time ny @rse.

They're paid professional sportsmen, they should be able to cope with another game within 5 days, if they can't they're not fit and shouldn't be picked.

Goto Thread: PreviousNext
Goto: Message ListLog In

Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.
We record all IP addresses on the Sportnetwork message boards which may be required by the authorities in case of defamatory or abusive comment. We seek to monitor the Message Boards at regular intervals. We do not associate Sportnetwork with any of the comments and do not take responsibility for any statements or opinions expressed on the Message Boards. If you have any cause for concern over any material posted here please let us know as soon as possible by e-mailing abuse@sportnetwork.net
 

Newcastle Falcons Poll

Do you think the coaching team of Alan Tait and Paul Moriarty should be replaced?