Username
Password
Castres Olympique 13 Leeds Carnegie 3

Yellow Carded...
By Peter Creek January 19 2008
Leeds Carnegie travelled to Castres for a mid-week tie knowing that a win would see them through to the quarterfinals of the European Challenge Cup. The French had signalled their intentions earlier in the week by announcing a strong team for the game. This was a winner takes all match with the losers having to wait for the weekend results to see if they would stay in the competition.

The game kicked off in torrential rain and there was a feeling that this “Yorkshire weather” would suit the visitors. We were expecting a contest of the two packs and so it proved as, for the first ten minutes, the Leeds forwards drove into the home defence. Villi Ma’asi led the charge showing his great appetite for the big hits and keeping the home defence on the back foot. On ten minutes an alarm sounded for the visitors as Castres broke up the field with a slick handling move involving forwards and backs although nothing came of it. The Carnegies cleared their lines but we had had a glimpse of  what the home side were capable of  even in such poor conditions. For the rest of the first half  Stuart Lancaster’s lads were on top. Lee Blackett was revelling in the conditions, chasing high balls and generally using his powerful physique to good effect. 

At half time the biggest surprise, apart from the fact that it was still raining, was that the score was still nil-nil. Leeds had had the majority of possession in the first half without really threatening to breach the home defence. The Carnegie fans believed that more of the same after the break would get the right result eventually. This was not the case as the French raised their game after the restart and errors started to creep into the Carnegie game. Once the good Doctor’s line kicks started missing touch it was only a matter of time before the home side were gifted a kickable penalty. On a night when it was obvious that points were going to be hard come by The Carnegies were soon six nil down. At this point we got a series of substitutions which were detrimental to the Leeds performance. At no point had Ma’asi shown any signs of tiring but he was taken off. However it was the replacement of Lee Blackett by Tuilagi that was to prove crucial in the end. The Samoan was not on the pitch very long before he was penalised for a high tackle. This must have set the referee against him as he was carded later for what seemed to be an innocuous hand–off. This was not the night to be playing a man short and the French forwards seized the initiative to score the only try of the game. The Doc finally got Leeds on the scoreboard and was close to securing a bonus point late on when his kick drifted wide of the posts. 

 Another disappointing defeat for Leeds then but at least the team has a ten-day break before the “cup final” against London Irish at Headingley Carnegie.


Bookmark or share this story with:

19 Jan, 2008 17:55 Report
merry (IP Logged)
Registered User
Date Joined: Jan, 2006
Location: york
Posts: 1854
Re: Castres Olympique 13 Leeds Carnegie 3
cheers for that, peter. so lee was 'revelling in the conditions'? bet he thought he was back in rotherham. winking smiley

ReplyQuote
19 Jan, 2008 19:57 Report
farmertyke (IP Logged)
Registered User
Date Joined: May, 2007
Location:
Posts: 399
Re: Castres Olympique 13 Leeds Carnegie 3
Maasi's substitution, unless he turns out to be injured, seemed an odd decision. He is not only hungry for the ball but carries it well. Surely at that stage of the match in those conditions that is exactly the player we needed on the pitch.

ReplyQuote
20 Jan, 2008 10:33 Report
SoopaLeeds (IP Logged)
Mystic Soopa
Date Joined: Jun, 2006
Location: On my Ar*e
Posts: 1274
Re: Castres Olympique 13 Leeds Carnegie 3
I suspect fatigue played a part. You can't always be action man for the full 80, I suspect he was asked to give it hell for 60 mins.

ReplyQuote
20 Jan, 2008 14:21 Report
Cholmondley-bin-Warner (IP Logged)
Registered User
Date Joined: Dec, 2004
Location: Abu Dhabi
Posts: 125
Re: Castres Olympique 13 Leeds Carnegie 3
SoopaLeeds - you may very well be correct about fatigue but I for one didn't see that in his play at the point of being sub'd. Maybe the switch was a bit too premeditated rather than tactical or because of injury/fatigue.
However I thought the team played well in the conditions just a bit unfortunate not to come away with some points.

ReplyQuote
20 Jan, 2008 15:46 Report
chumpy (IP Logged)
Registered User
Date Joined: Jan, 2007
Location:
Posts: 36
Re: Castres Olympique 13 Leeds Carnegie 3
thanks for the repotage. Not great coverage in nippon apart from the liecester v toulose game of 2 weeks ago.

sounds like a wet game and a bit parky
cheers,

chumpy

ReplyQuote
20 Jan, 2008 16:32 Report
Wildwillie (IP Logged)
Not so anxious now
Date Joined: Dec, 2006
Location: Up hill & down Dale
Posts: 2419
Re: Castres Olympique 13 Leeds Carnegie 3
Sayonara Chumpy - How were the Geisha girls?

(Sm134)

ReplyQuote
Goto Thread: PreviousNext
Goto: Message ListLog In

Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.
We record all IP addresses on the Sportnetwork message boards which may be required by the authorities in case of defamatory or abusive comment. We seek to monitor the Message Boards at regular intervals. We do not associate Sportnetwork with any of the comments and do not take responsibility for any statements or opinions expressed on the Message Boards. If you have any cause for concern over any material posted here please let us know as soon as possible by e-mailing abuse@sportnetwork.net