Username
Password
A Short Review of the Season

Celebrate Good Times!
By Andy Brown
May 20 2009
When Leeds Carnegie were relegated at the end of the 2007/8 season back down to National Division, the more ambitious of the national 1 clubs were sharpening their knives, ready to make an assault against the returning Leeds team.

When the likes of Harlequins and Northampton Saints had been relegated in previous years, it was assumed that these aristocrats of the rugby world would be far too strong for the ND1 opposition, and as a result, most of them didn't even try. But Leeds were viewed as there for the taking, and Exeter Chiefs, Doncaster Knights, Nottingham and others were waiting.

With a convincing win against Nottingham at Headingley in the first fixture of the season, followed by a narrow squeak away to Exeter, any nervousness amongst the hard-core Leeds fans was assauged somewhat.

The next few weeks were fairly workaday; the wide gap within the division that the RFU is now seeking to close by introducing a fully professional “Championship” meant that Leeds' next few games didn't raise much of a sweat (although Rotherham had a good forty minutes at Clifton Lane before Leeds' dominance was restored). Perhaps Leeds' best showing throughout the season was away to London Welsh, where by all accounts Leeds looked like a Premiership team in waiting once again.

As the cold winter closed in though, tougher times were ahead. Doncaster put the frighteners on the fans for a full sixty minutes at Headingley before Leeds were able to bring off the win. However the lack of the bonus point was seen as an opportunity missed, and with Exeter scoring bonus point wins every week, they were metaphorically breathing down the necks of the Yorkshire boys. With narrower and narrower wins over Bedford and Cornish Pirates, the bonus point situation was becoming a worry.

And then something pretty weird happened. Mid-December, Exeter managed the unthinkable and nearly lost a game against lowly Esher. They fought back for a 12-12 draw, but it was devastating for their season. From that point on, it was going to be plain sailing. The title belonged to Leeds.... surely?

In the new year, the National Trophy came to its fourth round stage, with Leeds drawn against Bristol's Dings Crusaders. The scoreline of 0-59 was impressive but somehow those of us that didn't make the long trip to the West Country expected more somehow. More easy wins over the next few weeks papered over the cracks, and another 59-0 win in the cup, this time against Coventry put the League and Cup double in the minds of us all.

Things aren't always what they seem. Playing Coventry again the following week, this time in the league and on a mud bog of a pitch at the Butts Park Arena, Leeds only just pulled off the win 11-15. Leeds won the following week against Esher, but only after leaking three tries – the most the frugal defence had ever let through in a match this season.

And the jitters were there in force when playing in the cup quarter-final against Birmingham, where the midlanders came to within two points of causing the biggest shock of the season. If there were any doubts that Leeds were on the ropes, these were swiftly demolished by Doncaster, who registered a spectacular win 27-12, and totally outplayed Leeds in all areas of the park. This was followed by another away loss to Bedford. Suddenly the class of the field had lost two games on the bounce, and the league title was in danger.

A tough away fixture at Nottingham for the cup semi final went a full seven minutes into added time, and the mental toughness that Neil Back and Andy Key had instilled in the Leeds lads really paid off giving a 13-14 win to the Yorkshire boys, and a trip to Twickenham to face Moseley. Having disposed of Moseley easily in the league earlier, the cup was as good as in the Headingley trophy cabinet. Wasn't it?

That self-same day, Exeter and Moseley had elected to double up their cup semi-final and league fixture, and this backfired hugely on Exeter, losing the match 32-24, and this time their title challenge was definitely finished. That week, they sacked their Director of Rugby and conceded the title. The trophy was awarded at Headingley on 11th April after a workaday victory over Newbury. Now all that remained was the cup at Twickenham...

...but the double just didn't happen. Moseley had done their homework and put together a game-plan that worked from the off and continued to work all the way through the match. Leeds didn't really turn up and the cup went to the Brummies – and well deserved it was too.

So promotion to the Guinness Premiership at the first time of asking was the goal, and it was achieved. Sadly though, the other – admittedly less important – target of an unbeaten season and a league and cup double didn't materialise, and this has raised fear, uncertainty and doubt for next season. How can Leeds compete in the Premiership if they can do no better than scrape past the National 1 clubs? And with the announcement of Carnegie's withdrawl from ownership of the club, how does the financial position of the club affect their ability to compete next season?

I am optimistic. The connection with Leeds Met University was an interesting experiment, but one that was shaped wrongly. With Paul Caddick back in the chairmanship, we have a man who is passionate about having top-class rugby – of both codes – in the city, and he will do all in his power to ensure the investment required to build a strong Premiership is forthcoming – look out for future announcements on sponsorships and partnerships that will enable Leeds to take a further step onwards. And with Andy Key and Neil Back in charge of playing matters, we couldn't have a better coaching team to attract and energise the right blend of players to create a lasting Premiership legacy. We are already on tenterhooks waiting for some imminent announcements on recruitment.

Next season is about survival in the Premiership. Subsequent seasons will be about consolidating and moving up the table, ultimately to become a team that finishes regularly in the top four. This is some way off, but these are exciting times at Headingley, and rugby fans across the whole of Yorkshire can look forward to a golden age. Can't they?

View a Printer Friendly version of this Story.

Bookmark or share this story with:

20 May, 2009 20:50 Report
TykesRugby.co.uk (IP Logged)
Unregistered User
A Short Review of the Season
What do you think? You can have your say by posting below.
If you do not already have an account Click here to Register.

ReplyQuote
20 May, 2009 21:15 Report
leedscboy (IP Logged)
Registered User
Date Joined: Apr, 2008
Location:
Posts: 2873
Re: A Short Review of the Season
(Sm152)

Thanks.

Pain is only temporary but victory is forever

ReplyQuote
20 May, 2009 21:47 Report
Timofe (IP Logged)
The Enchanter
Date Joined: Sep, 2003
Location: Behind a big drum
Posts: 4687
Re: A Short Review of the Season
At the risk of sounding disrespectful to the rest, we won the league by five wins, with third place a further two wins below that, points-wise.

Yes, we were nervous when we lost two games in a row, but the lack of respect offered to Leeds at the start of the season by the teams you mention Andy, was clearly misplaced.

Next year will be a struggle, but Leeds are clearly better than the rest of National 1. I just hope we don't yo-yo again.

Drinking for two

ReplyQuote
20 May, 2009 22:03 Report
Munkitastik (IP Logged)
Registered User
Date Joined: Apr, 2007
Location: Here There and Everywhere
Posts: 144
Re: A Short Review of the Season
Cheers Andy, that brought it all back home, I am optimistic for next season but we do really have to raise our game however I do trust that we have the best mangement structure to do so....

ReplyQuote
20 May, 2009 23:26 Report
Tufty the Tyke (IP Logged)
Registered User
Date Joined: Apr, 2008
Location: 'Uddersfelt
Posts: 519
Re: A Short Review of the Season
Thanks Andy, I think that sums it up very well. Tim was correct with we were the best side in the division, but it all starts again from here. I'm positive we are not going to be a yo-yo team again. Come on yew Tykes!!

ReplyQuote
21 May, 2009 14:05 Report
farmertyke (IP Logged)
Registered User
Date Joined: Apr, 2007
Location:
Posts: 1582
Re: A Short Review of the Season
Thank you Andy. I often wonder why the team lost their way mid season. They had lost the odd key player notably Fourie through injury but did team rotation mean that the players did not quite gel in certain areas. The cup final was odd as they were comprehensibly outplayed.

ReplyQuote
21 May, 2009 14:18 Report
Bibby (IP Logged)
Registered User
Date Joined: Sep, 2008
Location: Headingley
Posts: 793
Re: A Short Review of the Season
Good effort, an exciting season all round.

Call me picky, but somehow I enjoyed the last promotion season even more, but that was probably because we did it after the mass exodus and so it seemed less likely. This time round we started off the season wth more reasons to be optimistic and so it was more of a worry when Exeter matched us, almost, and for about 3 panicky weeks we had the '09 stumbles.

ReplyQuote
21 May, 2009 15:07 Report
Freddy (IP Logged)
Principled Individual
Date Joined: Jul, 2006
Location:
Posts: 7968
Re: A Short Review of the Season
Really good read. Well done sums it up perfectly.

Serenity. why lose your temper if by losing it you offend God, you trouble your neighbor, your give yourself a bad time... and in the end you have to set things aright anyway?

ReplyQuote
Goto Thread: PreviousNext
Goto: Message ListLog In

Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.
We record all IP addresses on the Sportnetwork message boards which may be required by the authorities in case of defamatory or abusive comment. We seek to monitor the Message Boards at regular intervals. We do not associate Sportnetwork with any of the comments and do not take responsibility for any statements or opinions expressed on the Message Boards. If you have any cause for concern over any material posted here please let us know as soon as possible by e-mailing abuse@sportnetwork.net
 

Leeds Carnegie Poll

So where will we be next season?