Username
Password
Developmental Rugby - How's it Doing?

England U20s Skipper
By Andy Brown
June 22 2009
Desparate for inspiration, and wanting, for the moment at least, to turn away from the Lions tour, I thought it would be worth stopping for a moment and considering the value of the various other tours that are taking place around this time.

The IRB have been trying to generate interest in the game around the world, and also to help the second and third tier nations get higher quality regular games at international level to increase skill levels, intensity, and obviously to generate a bit of national pride.

Top of the list of these is the Churchill Cup. Annually played in North America, it is usually contested between England Saxons, Canada, USA, Argentina A and other tier 1 A teams, this year including Ireland A the eventual winners of the cup itself. The crowds in North America have not, however, been much to write home about, and it seems as if this particular tournament has lost a little bit of its sheen. How does one breathe a bit of life into it?

Well, the fact that it's had someone different winning it this time might help. The Irish team apparently dismantled Stuart Lancaster's Saxons team in the final, and it shows that Ireland's provincial system really does seem to be producing talented players who can make in in the international context. With the Saxons having won the previous two years, seemingly at a canter, this result could've been just what the doctor ordered. And with Mike MacDonald's USA team getting one of the consolation trophies, the locals had something to cheer.

In a similar vein, there is also the regular annual Pacific Nations Cup, fought between the island rugby nations of Tonga, Fiji and Samoa, with the Junior All Blacks, a Japan team and until this year, Australia A. In 2009, the ARU pulled out of the tournament, citing the economic slowdown as a reason for not assembling a junior Wallabies side. It is perhaps this same economic downturn that has caused the tournament to require less travelling for the participating nations, with the matches being hosted almost entirely this year in Fiji for a seventeen day festival of rugby, the exceptions being the first two matches of the tournament.

These two matches were excellent affairs; a narrow win for the JABs 17-16 over Samoa at Apia and a relatively easy win for Fiji 36-22 over Tonga. Japan's first taste of action this year was a tough encounter with Samoa where they went down 34-15, while the Junior All Blacks gained some momentum with a stonking 45-17 victory over the home side Fiji.

In the short history of this tournament, only New Zealand sides have ever won it (the New Zealand Maori team were representing the country in 2008) and it could perhaps be argued that - as in the Churchill Cup of late - it's getting a bit monotonous. However what makes it different is that all the countries involved in the tournament are passionate rugby nations - yes, even Japan - and that they will continue to do battle and hope one day to take it away from the JABs.

The other showcase for emerging talent was the U20s World Championship, held every year in a single location a la the Rugby World Cup, and this time there is no second-string nature to the competition. Each participating nation sends its age-group qualified best players, and in a repeat of last year's encounter in Wales, it was England versus New Zealand in the final, held in Japan. In a repeat of the result as well, the Baby Blacks beat a combative and resourceful England side; the downfall of the boys in white being the sheer brilliance of the New Zealanders' back division.

So there are annual tournaments a plenty, which means for the stay-at-home fan there is always an international match to look forward to, regardless of how hot the summer sun is in dear old Blighty. What it does mean though, is that there is some regular representative rugby for these lower level rugby playing nations, and it is hoped that in time these competitions, or at any rate their successors, will become as prized as the Six Nations in the north or the Tri-Nations in the south.

But the big unsolved question is: What about Argentina?

View a Printer Friendly version of this Story.

Bookmark or share this story with:

22 Jun, 2009 22:07 Report
TykesRugby.co.uk (IP Logged)
Unregistered User
Developmental Rugby - How's it Doing?
What do you think? You can have your say by posting below.
If you do not already have an account Click here to Register.

ReplyQuote
23 Jun, 2009 09:58 Report
Bibby (IP Logged)
Registered User
Date Joined: Sep, 2008
Location:
Posts: 442
Re: Developmental Rugby - How's it Doing?
Interesting.

There's also the conflict between development games and burnout.

Do people like Calum, Mac, Gomes and old boy Hoops actually get any rest at all? We've been in pre-season training for a while now, so do they come back from U20's or Churchill Cup and go straight back to it? I bet they couldn't have a break before their tournaments.

Money wise, are any of these tournaments anywhere near self funding? I bet there's not much TV money and the gates are poor. IRB have to steer a tricky course, but I still think they missed a trick in not going to Japan for the next RWC.

ReplyQuote
23 Jun, 2009 11:48 Report
Freddy Leamy (IP Logged)
Registered User
Date Joined: Jul, 2006
Location:
Posts: 3741
Re: Developmental Rugby - How's it Doing?
As for the churchill cup, there is no fun if you support Canada seeing your team smashed every game, and unless England, Ireland etc bring big names to the tournament what is there in it for the casual supporter. ITs a bit like watching Leeds Tykes in the GP last time, no fun seeing your team smashed but a little bit of interest seeing the stars of the opposition team. As a supporter you would rather see your team being competitve against the best...its a chicken and egg thing

Next time, Harry, we won't play by their rules. We'll invent our own!

ReplyQuote
23 Jun, 2009 12:20 Report
*baldric* (IP Logged)
Cunning
Date Joined: Mar, 2005
Location:
Posts: 1279
Re: Developmental Rugby - How's it Doing?
I hope they return the Churchill Cup to Canada soon - if it had been in Toronto/Edmonton again this year I'd have probably gone (have friends near Edmonton, and from my 2 days in Toronto previously I think I'd like another trip)

Mind you, I wouldn't mind it going to Vancouver either - I was led to believe that there's quite a good rugby scene there by a couple of local players/coaches there (who bought me several beers and chatted for hours once they'd discovered I was a rugby fan)

Still a Tyke - whatever the name!

ReplyQuote
23 Jun, 2009 12:29 Report
Rocky The Tyke (IP Logged)
Registered User
Date Joined: Jan, 2005
Location: T'other side of the Pennines
Posts: 1200
Re: Developmental Rugby - How's it Doing?
There was worries that the Churchill Cup would not be happening next year due to issues with Barclays sponsorship. Apparently the funding was in place for this years but who knows about 2010's tournament.

__________________________________

The time for reminiscing is after rugby. Then you can sit down and get fat.

Quote from Josh Lewsey

ReplyQuote
23 Jun, 2009 14:07 Report
Freddy Leamy (IP Logged)
Registered User
Date Joined: Jul, 2006
Location:
Posts: 3741
Re: Developmental Rugby - How's it Doing?
Its very much a minority sport in canada and USA.

Next time, Harry, we won't play by their rules. We'll invent our own!

ReplyQuote
Goto Thread: PreviousNext
Goto: Message ListLog In

Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.
We record all IP addresses on the Sportnetwork message boards which may be required by the authorities in case of defamatory or abusive comment. We seek to monitor the Message Boards at regular intervals. We do not associate Sportnetwork with any of the comments and do not take responsibility for any statements or opinions expressed on the Message Boards. If you have any cause for concern over any material posted here please let us know as soon as possible by e-mailing abuse@sportnetwork.net
 

Leeds Carnegie Poll

The season has started, and we've seen the lads play a game. So, where in the table, on that performance, will we likely finish?