Username
Password
Middlesex Sevens: Anachronism or Season's Appetiser?

Keeping Busy at Twix
By Andy Brown
August 13 2009
This coming weekend sees the gathering of all twelve Guinness Premiership clubs plus a few other noteworthy “Barbarians” style teams to contest the annual Middlesex Sevens. This has been a regular fixture as a sevens tourrnament for as long aas anyone can remember, and, since the onset of professionalism in Rugby Union, has always included teams from the top flight of English rugby.

However, looking at the team sheets submitted to the organisers, it looks to me that the Premiership clubs especially are not really treating this competition as something worthy of too much attention, so it let me to ask the question in the title of this article.

In the good old days, there was a time when the Middlesex Sevens was a purely invitational tournament, which meant not much more than a fun day out for whoever chose to show up on the day, with the added spice for the players involved on playing a game – albeit a shortened form which shouldn't be confused with proper rugby (although one worries that the IOC might be thinking this week that Sevens is the way of the future) – on the hallowed turf of the home of English rugby. In those days, Twickenham matches were restricted to full England internationals and cup finals. The chances of any one individual player appearing for their club or country on that basis was so amazingly low, that the Sevens could have been seen as a way of being able to tell your grandchildren “I played there once you know!”.

In the sense of the meaningfulness of the tournament, not much has changed. Its a bit of a runabout on the day, but in these times of robust dietary programmes and rigid training regimes, playing a sevens tournanment a couple of weeks before the main start of the season offers nothing but negatives to a team in the Premiership. Nothing can be learned from performances or playing patterns in the games on the day (it's Sevens, remember!), and one runs the risk of taking a hit that gets you injured before the season starts. No wonder very few GP teams have named obvious first-team contenders in their line-ups for the weekend.

For the supporters too, the trip to Twickers has palled as an event in recent years. London-based rugby fans (and go on, admit it, the majority of the Middlesex Sevens tickets will be sold to stockbroker-belt attendees) are now used to the regular double-header at the start of the season, and with the onset of the playoffs as a concept for deciding the Premiership champions, another Twickenham date awaits. The pilgrimage to TW19 has transposed itself from the Middlesex Sevens to the double-header as the herald of the season's start, leaving the charity event lacking in a certain charisma.

The tykesrugby.co.uk website is so bristling with enthusiasm about the event that I don't remember reading a single post about the topic.

To my mind, the announcement of the inclusion of sevens into the Olympic programme of 2016 will engender a bit of interest in the sport this weekend – something obviously serendipitous that the organisers will be hugely foolish to miss out on the connection. But if they want Middlesex to be considered a top tournament for sevens, it's time it was revamped.

The club sides are not interested, and the fans are in danger of becoming equally blasé about the tournament, so I believe it is a good time to turn the Middlesex Sevens into a quasi-international affair, and perhaps link it in some way into the IRB international sevens series. There is already the “London Sevens” in that series, so it obviously couldn't really become a round in its own right, but perhaps it could become something of a “World Sevens Championship” for under-20 players for example.

View a Printer Friendly version of this Story.

Bookmark or share this story with:

13 Aug, 2009 22:14 Report
TykesRugby.co.uk (IP Logged)
Unregistered User
Middlesex Sevens: Anachroism or Season's Appetiser?
What do you think? You can have your say by posting below.
If you do not already have an account Click here to Register.

ReplyQuote
14 Aug, 2009 04:37 Report
Madtyke (IP Logged)
Registered User
Date Joined: Sep, 2003
Location: In God's Country
Posts: 787
Re: Middlesex Sevens: Anachroism or Season's Appetiser?
I concor with the point that GP sides disrespect the Tournament as it interferes with the pre-season build-up.

Also Thank God you wrote this APB, the sight of James Corden and his socks was scaring my young'un everytime he looked over my shoulder as I logged onto the site.

[:wor kid:]

http://www.danasoft.com/sig/443863.jpg

[www.arborfieldoldboys.co.uk]

ReplyQuote
14 Aug, 2009 07:45 Report
Mark_C (IP Logged)
Original Cult
Date Joined: Sep, 2004
Location: In at the Back
Posts: 4589
Re: Middlesex Sevens: Anachroism or Season's Appetiser?
I used to enjoy the Sevens, I remember when Wigan first appeared in it several years ago and ran the pants of everybody!

Would have gone if there had been a trip organised, I think.

ReplyQuote
14 Aug, 2009 09:01 Report
barney1985 (IP Logged)
Registered User
Date Joined: May, 2009
Location:
Posts: 5
Re: Middlesex Sevens: Anachroism or Season's Appetiser?
I don't think the middlesex 7s interrupts GP teams pre season, i think it give a fantastic opportunity for coaches to look at players in a highly pressured and competitive environment. Admittedly the patterns will differ, however middlesex 7s is a fantastic stepping stone to 1st team rugby, and much like the England 7s team is a stepping stone to full international honours.
Not to mention what a belting day out Middlesex 7s is! Tomorrow Twickenham will be full of a great mixture of people young and old.

ReplyQuote
14 Aug, 2009 14:09 Report
JDH (IP Logged)
Registered User
Date Joined: Apr, 2007
Location:
Posts: 746
Re: Middlesex Sevens: Anachroism or Season's Appetiser?
I went down last year for the first time and had a cracking day!

The fans are superb and the scheduling of the comp means you can dip in and out etc

I would keep it to GP sides. I would rather watch a second string leeds side than international U20s any day.

ReplyQuote
15 Aug, 2009 13:25 Report
SoopaLeeds (IP Logged)
The Glo-Hat master
Date Joined: Jun, 2006
Location: On my Ar*e
Posts: 1882
Re: Middlesex Sevens: Anachroism or Season's Appetiser?
Today's tournamnet has been good so far. I see there is a link to the 7's circuit with the arrival of invitational sides featuring for example the Kenyans star players.
London irish have put a first team in, including both Armitages, Peter Richards, Thakinbau etc. even if others (like us) have used kids.

I think, given the olympic thumbs up, that rugby 7's is becoming bigger in its own right and this tournament is a key part of its success.

ReplyQuote
16 Aug, 2009 12:10 Report
PorthosTyke (IP Logged)
Sender of food parcels to Fosi.
Date Joined: Nov, 2006
Location: Arcadia, usually.
Posts: 376
Re: Middlesex Sevens: Anachroism or Season's Appetiser?
It was a fine day out.

Irish were always going to do well, being about the only Premiership side to pick first choice players. Once they'd beaten the Army that was it really.

The Tykes lads did well to beat Wasps, but the invitational side they lost to in the second round had a bit too much for them. Gomersall looked class.

Good to see Twiggy playing for Sale. He's still not learned to pass (a handicap in Sevens).

AramisTyke and I saw one other Tykes supporter there. Was it anyone on here?

PT

ReplyQuote
16 Aug, 2009 21:55 Report
baggie (IP Logged)
Registered User
Date Joined: Oct, 2005
Location:
Posts: 308
Re: Middlesex Sevens: Anachroism or Season's Appetiser?
Yesterday was the first time we had been to the Middlesex Sevens and we thoroughly enjoyed the day - meeting old friends & making new ones.

Interesting article - my information is that the format of the competition will change next year and the GP clubs will be excluded - precisely for some of the reasons stated, e.g. fielding "weakened" sides or originally naming a strong squad and then diluting it before the day.

Most of the GP clubs were starting their pre-season friendlies this weekend so the Sevens was an extra call on their playing resources at a time when their top priority was preparation for the new league season.

ReplyQuote
17 Aug, 2009 07:04 Report
rotherhamtillidie (IP Logged)
Registered User
Date Joined: Aug, 2006
Location:
Posts: 530
Re: Middlesex Sevens: Anachroism or Season's Appetiser?
You get out what you put into something. I understand why london irish gave their better players a run out, and think it was a great idea. They'll have a buzz around the squad now, I think they therefore "gained" something from it.

I really like the short format of the game and am very pleased its in the olympics. It forces players to focus on 1 on 1's and rewards speed and skill over strength, which has allowed several players to develop their running games e.g. strettle.

I think its a shame premiership clubs have chosen not to take it seriously, and while this is understandable for the reasons mentionned in the article above, with squad sizes on average 35 and another 25 academy players its a shame they couldn't give a run out to atleast a couple of first team players each!!

I wonder if part of the decline in the middlesex 7's is about clubs "acting" more professionally as opposed to being more professional. Rugby union still has a long long way to go in terms of its development as a pro sport and I think this is a sad symptom of attempts to be more professional.

The most professional rugby team ever is maybe the wigan side of the 90's, and if my memory serves me correctly the won this title!? I think this competition needs a complete re-think, and maybe once its sorted itself out, and when premiership clubs have more confidence in their ability as a group of athletes, and confidence that the competition is marketed (has the right status for them to bother turning out a decent side) correctly they will return.

ReplyQuote
19 Aug, 2009 16:44 Report
Freddy Leamy (IP Logged)
Registered User
Date Joined: Jul, 2006
Location:
Posts: 3760
Re: Middlesex Sevens: Anachroism or Season's Appetiser?
I like 7s rugby but I always see it as an end of season/closed season tournament thing rather than a new season curtain raiser. All the same I do enjoy it.

Next time, Harry, we won't play by their rules. We'll invent our own!

ReplyQuote
19 Aug, 2009 17:46 Report
Catchyerselfon2 (IP Logged)
Registered User
Date Joined: Apr, 2007
Location:
Posts: 4474
Re: Middlesex Sevens: Anachroism or Season's Appetiser?
I have to say, as a former winger, the 7's circuit was always something that happened from Easter onwards rather than the build-up to the new season and although I can see the benefits of playing it at the start, I know I would rather be involved with the XV man version of the game when the season's start is so close

ReplyQuote
19 Aug, 2009 18:55 Report
Loosehead (IP Logged)
Registered User
Date Joined: Sep, 2003
Location:
Posts: 5743
Re: Middlesex Sevens: Anachroism or Season's Appetiser?
Why not make it for players 23 and Under

ReplyQuote
20 Aug, 2009 09:30 Report
apb (IP Logged)
Yo-Yo Prohibited
Date Joined: Sep, 2003
Location:
Posts: 3885
Re: Middlesex Sevens: Anachroism or Season's Appetiser?
The point is, if the Middx 7s wants to be anything more than "Thin Blokes Sevens" (i.e. just another stroll about for a few players) then it needs to reinvent itself in such a way that it will attract the punters in and the attention. Its not doing that job now.

Moderator

TykesRugby.co.uk
LeedsCarnegieFans.co.uk

Unofficial Fans Forum Supporting Leeds RU since 2002

TykesRugby.co.uk is sponsoring SCOTT MATHIE for Season 2009/10

ReplyQuote
Goto Thread: PreviousNext
Goto: Message ListLog In

Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.
We record all IP addresses on the Sportnetwork message boards which may be required by the authorities in case of defamatory or abusive comment. We seek to monitor the Message Boards at regular intervals. We do not associate Sportnetwork with any of the comments and do not take responsibility for any statements or opinions expressed on the Message Boards. If you have any cause for concern over any material posted here please let us know as soon as possible by e-mailing abuse@sportnetwork.net
 

Leeds Carnegie Poll

The season has started, and we've seen the lads play a game. So, where in the table, on that performance, will we likely finish?