Username
Password
Leicester Tigers 27-14 Harlequins
By AlanQuin
November 23 2008
Success at Welford Road is a distant folk memory for Harlequins.  In the Premiership it continues to elude Harlequins as a poor performance, not assisted by some glaring refereeing errors, allowed Leicester to win easily 27–14. Andy Gomarsall had withdrawn in the morning his shoulder injury not being sufficiently recovered and Junior Polou replaced him with Gareth Williams coming on to the bench.

There was a disastrous start to the match as Mike Brown, principally, and others failed to gather the kick off. It was allowed to bounce and fell into Leicester hands.   Immense pressure on the Quins line on the right was held but the ball was moved rapidly left to reach Johne Murphy unmarked on the wing for a try inside the first minute.  Hougaard’s excellent kick from the touchline rubbed salt into the wound as Tigers opened a seven point lead.  Only five minutes later Guest was penalised for holding on when iosolated at a breakdown on the Quins twenty-two and Hougaard increased the lead.

Quins attempted to rally and with possession came territory and after a few minutes more Nick Evans made no mistake with a penalty.  But barely a minute later Hougaard took a similar opportunity. After eleven minutes the score was 13 – 3.

There was no shortage of effort as Quins tried to catch up.  But the Tigers are streetwise and defend with skill and determination.  Their kicking game caused Quins problems.  Masson and Turner-Hall worked hard in attack and frequently appeared to be making progress only to run into the wall of the Tigers’ defence.  Another penalty allowed Evans to narrow the gap again.

Again Quins failed to deal with a restart and immediately Leicester was on the attack again as Hipkiss and Mauger penetrated deep into Quins’ territory and found Hougaard able to cross for an easy score and a successful conversion.   Quins increased their efforts in attack and a fine break by Tom Williams was halted short of the line and all that Quins could achieve was another penalty from Nick Evans that took the score at half-time to 20 – 9.

The second half started almost as poorly as the first half had.  The Leicester right wing, Matt Smith, attacked down the right and chipped hard over the defence and his chase was ruled as a try, despite being clearly touched down over the dead ball line,

with the referee and his assistant a long way behind.  Dean Richards later averred that the video of the match confirmed the error.  With Hougaard adding the conversion the Tigers’ lead was now 27 – 9.

A further error from the referee in respect of a very long kick from Mike Brown brought play back to the Quins’ twenty-two although it had been kicked from inside the area and had not been taken back inside by Brown.  The benefit of position and possession was all that Tigers needed to keep Quins back in their own half.

While Quins were now playing with more skill and determination than earlier in the game, they were forced to chase and take chances that did not succeed. More than once they took play down to the Tigers five metre line but then either a knock-on or a turnover allowed Leicester to clear.    Penalty opportunities were kicked to the corner in an attempt to force a try but at least twice the chance was lost when the throw was penalised for not being straight.

Despite having lost Gary Botha with an injury just before half-time, the scrum was holding up well, disrupting the Leicester set-piece and holding firm on their own ball with Chris Brooker showing his skills.  With three minutes remaining it was Brooker that broke through from a breakdown on the Tiger’s ten-metre line to run almost unopposed for a try that even he was surprised by.  The conversion was missed and the match ended with the score at 27 – 14,

At the press conference after the game, Dean Richards was clearly unhappy at Quins’ performance and admitted that the loss was self-inflicted. "We gave Leicester the first 13 points," he said. "The first kick-off, we have lost it and they have scored. We get a kick-off again and we have dropped it again and they have scored another. They are 10-3 up with only 10 minutes gone. You can't allow yourself to come to a place like this and have to try to claw yourself back into a game early on.”

He went on "Matt Smith's try was well over the dead-ball line yet it was still given. It was a game-changing decision, the wrong decision.”  Asked how he was certain that were so, he confirmed that the video of the match showed it clearly.  He was also scathing about the decision over Brown’s kick, but went on, "If you don't get help here you are never going to win. I am not going to blame the ref because all in all the blame lies with ourselves because of our poor start."

LEICESTER TIGERS: S Hamilton; J Murphy (T Varndell 65min), D Hipkiss, A Mauger, M Smith, D Hougaard (S Vesty 77min), J Dupuy (B Youngs 75min); B Stankovich (S Bonorino 64-67min), G Chuter (M Davies 61min), D Cole (S Bonorino 69min), M Corry (capt), B Kay, C Newby, B Deacon, L Moody

HARLEQUINS :M Brown; T Williams, T Masson (DW Barry 78min), J Turner-Hall, C Amesbury, N Evans, J Polu (G Williams 76min), M Ross (M Lambert 67min), G Botha (capt) (C Brooker 39min), C Jones, J Evans, O Kohn (G Robson 61min), C Robshaw, T Guest, N McMillan

Referee: S Davey (RFU)

Attendance: 17,432

View a Printer Friendly version of this Story.

Bookmark or share this story with:

Leicester Tigers 27-14 Harlequins
Posted by: ComeAllWithin.co.uk (IP Logged)
Date: 23/11/2008 16:48

Leicester Tigers 27-14 Harlequins

Re: Leicester Tigers 27-14 Harlequins
Posted by: The Prof (IP Logged)
Date: 23/11/2008 16:49

Many thanks Alan

Re: Leicester Tigers 27-14 Harlequins
Posted by: Harley Quin (IP Logged)
Date: 23/11/2008 18:52

A very accurate representation of a very frustrating afternoon. Thanks AlanQuin.

Re: Leicester Tigers 27-14 Harlequins
Posted by: JTD (IP Logged)
Date: 23/11/2008 19:01

Frustrating to watch! Reading the match report brought the frustration back again. I haven't seen a replay of that 'try' yet. Grrrr.

Re: Leicester Tigers 27-14 Harlequins
Posted by: Quaking Quin (IP Logged)
Date: 23/11/2008 22:53

They didn't show the Mike Brown 'mark' on ITV 4, but Matt Smith touched the ball down well inside the deadball line. The question is whether his front foot went out before he grounded the ball. A TMO would have needed several replays to decide - the ref would have seen the ball going down inside the line. And as they say - the ref plays what he sees.

By all accounts Quins were still in Wasps glory mode. Tigers put the pressure on at key periods in both halfs. Quins played some token rugby in the last 15 minutes to no effect.

What a waste.

I wonder which Quins team will turn up against Bath?

Re: Leicester Tigers 27-14 Harlequins
Posted by: Alanquin (IP Logged)
Date: 24/11/2008 00:25

I reported what Deano said in the press conference about the try. The other matter I could see clearly from the press box.

Re: Leicester Tigers 27-14 Harlequins
Posted by: E-Quin (IP Logged)
Date: 24/11/2008 16:09

Quote:
Alanquin
I reported what Deano said in the press conference about the try. The other matter I could see clearly from the press box.

Err not quite. Your report says "The Leicester right wing, Matt Smith, attacked down the right and chipped hard over the defence and his chase was ruled as a try, despite being clearly touched down over the dead ball line",

Or did Deano write the match report in the press conference?

Goto Thread: PreviousNext
Goto: Message ListLog In

SPORTS SPREAD BETTING

Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.
We record all IP addresses on the Sportnetwork message boards which may be required by the authorities in case of defamatory or abusive comment. We seek to monitor the Message Boards at regular intervals. We do not associate Sportnetwork with any of the comments and do not take responsibility for any statements or opinions expressed on the Message Boards. If you have any cause for concern over any material posted here please let us know as soon as possible by e-mailing abuse@sportnetwork.net