Username
Password
South Africa v Lions (2nd Test) Match Review
By Patrick
June 29 2009
The British and Irish Lions' hopes of squaring the series in South Africa ended in heart-breaking fashion as replacement Springboks fly-half Morne Steyn landed a winning penalty with the last kick of a thrilling second Test in Pretoria.
Untitled Document

South Africa v British & Irish Lions (2nd Test)

South Africa sealed the series at the weekend with a 28-25 victory over the British and Irish Lions, in a match that like last week, went down to the very last play of the game. On the pitch, heartbreak and desolation from the Lions mixed with elation from the Springbok camp as they finally avenged their series defeat from twelve years ago. The first Test the previous week proved to be only an appetizer for what transpired in Pretoria: physicality, skill, tension and controversy were brought up several notches in what surely ended up being one of the most remarkable Lions Test matches of the professional era. In the end however, the match was won with Bulls fly-half Morne Steyn landing a penalty as the clock ticked over the 80 minute mark to crush the hopes of the tourists and their army of travelling fans.

Steyn's kick ended a game of fantastic drama and fierce combat, in which the Lions had given up a 16-8 half-time lead thanks to a try from the hugely impressive Irish fullback, Rob Kearney. The Springboks scored tries of their own through JP Pietersen, Bryan Habana and Jaque Fourie, but were kept honest by a majestic performance with the boot from Welsh fly-half Stephen Jones.

Unfortunately for the tourists, they suffered a raft of injuries in the closing stages, with both props and centres all limping from the field. Adam Jones made a fine impact at the scrum after being called in in-place of Phil Vickery, while veteran lock Simon Shaw was a giant for the duration of the match.



In the end, the Springboks looked to have conceded the draw after Steyn saw a drop goal roll harmlessly in to the arms of Kearney, only for one last blow of the referee's whistle to hand the Bulls man his shot at a place in history. O'Gara, chasing his own kick, knocked du Preez out of the air and conceded a penalty 50 metres out. Steyn, with a swagger belying his inexperience, sent the kick straight and true to break the hearts of the Lions.

The Lions did all that was asked of them to take control of pulsating contest - displaying a hunger and a clinical edge that was sorely missing last weekend in Durban. But to their credit the Springboks weathered that storm and took the lead for the first time in the game with just a few minutes to go. The Lions climbed off the ropes in the closing moments to level the scores and it looked like they would at least keep the series alive heading to Johannesburg next weekend but it was not to be.



The injuries most certainly took their toll. Up front, the loss of both props didn’t allow the Lions to further impose their domination in the scrums, particularly with a fired up Andy Sheridan on the pitch. The backline without Roberts and O’Driscoll lacked both the physical presence, ball-carrying ability and the defensive organisation both players offer. And all this was happening as South Africa grew into the game, showing superb character and resilience to claw their way back into contention and eventually seal the win.

Springbok celebrations may be tempered following the game by a citing for flanker Schalk Burger, recalled to win his 50th cap, who was sin-binned in the opening minute for making contact with the eyes of debutant Lions wing Luke Fitzgerald. The Springbok flanker ended up receiving an eight-week ban for his troubles, in what surely deserved a red-card during the match.



It was a shame the contest was reduced to uncontested scrums before the game was an hour old, especially considering the dominance the Lions had in this area. This latest high-profile example of a match being marred by the lack of prop replacements must surely bring changes from the International Rugby Board. But not even that disappointing turn of events could overshadow what was one of the great international contests.

As opposed to the shambles of 2005, the class of 2009 and the tour in general could not have been more different. Once the devastation of two closely-fought losses begins to fade, this group of players will be able to hold their heads up high, not only with their performances on and off the pitch thus far, but also in the way they have promoted the Lions brand, and stood up to the challenge.


Player Ratings:

Rob Kearney
- 9 – Majestic, particularly in the first half. Excellent under high ball, great boot and fantastic finishing for his try.
Tommy Bowe 6 – A quiet game without many opportunities with ball in hand. Solid in defense.
Brian O’Driscoll 7 – Fully up for the challenge and showed his class time and time again with some excellent runs and great defense. A big loss to the team when he was forced off injured.
Jamie Roberts6 – Not quite as influential this week, as the Boks midfield defense was much improved. Still put in some strong ball carrying and tackling.
Luke Fitzgerald - 6 – Apart from a couple of strong runs, another quiet game on the wing.
Stephen Jones 7 – Near faultless with the boot, and ran the backline superbly. Created the try for Kearney.
Mike Phillips – 7 – Improved performance from last week. A big threat around the fringes, and a couple of good charges up the middle, but pass and decision-making needs to improve.

Gethin Jenkins 6 – Secure at scrum time and showed up well in the loose.
Matthew Rees 6 – Lost a fair number of lineouts due to poor throwing in, two of which proved very costly. Decent ball carrying in the loose.
Adam Jones – 7 – Scrummaged well to contain and dominate ‘the Beast’, and put in some important tackles.
Simon Shaw - 9 – A rock under the high ball, good in the lineout, a monster in defense and put in some very strong carries. Outplayed both Botha and Matfield and was everywhere on the pitch. A couple too many soft penalties though.
Paul O’Connell 6 – Wasn’t at his ball-carrying best but showed up well in the lineout and won a couple of turnovers late on.
Tom Croft – 6 – Not quite as omnipresent as he was in the first Test, but still guaranteed quality ball from the lineout. Good defense save for a couple of uncharacteristic lapses.
David Wallace7 – A total nuisance to the Boks at the breakdown allied with some strong carrying.
Jamie Heaslip – 6 – Put in the most number of tackles, but was again relatively quiet in attack, in stark contrast to the pace and power of opposite number Pierre Spies.

Replacements:
Andy Sheridan 7, Alun-Wyn Jones 6, Shane Williams 6, Martyn Williams 6, Ronan O’Gara 3


South Africa (8) 28
Tries:
Pietersen, Habana, Fourie Con: M Steyn 2 Pens: F Steyn, M Steyn 2

Lions (16) 25
Tries:
Kearney Con: S Jones Pens: S Jones 5 Drop-goal: S Jones


South Africa: Frans Steyn, JP Pietersen, Adi Jacobs, Jean de Villiers, Bryan Habana, Ruan Pienaar, Fourie du Preez, Pierre Spies, Juan Smith, Schalk Burger, Victor Matfield, Bakkies Botha, John Smit (captain), Bismarck du Plessis, Tendai Mtawarira

Replacements: Chiliboy Ralepelle, Deon Carstens, Andries Bekker, Danie Rossouw, Heinrich Brüssow, Jaque Fourie, Morné Steyn

British & Irish Lions: Rob Kearney (Leinster & Ireland), Tommy Bowe (Ospreys & Ireland), Brian O'Driscoll (Leinster & Ireland), Jamie Roberts (Cardiff Blues & Wales), Luke Fitzgerald (Leinster & Ireland), Stephen Jones (Scarlets & Wales), Mike Phillips (Ospreys & Wales), Jamie Heaslip (Leinster & Ireland), David Wallace (Munster & Ireland), Tom Croft (Leicester Tigers & England), Paul O'Connell (Munster & Ireland, captain), Simon Shaw (London Wasps & England), Adam Jones (Ospreys & Wales), Matthew Rees (Scarlets & Wales), Gethin Jenkins (Cardiff Blues & Wales)

Replacements: Ross Ford (Edinburgh & Scotland), Andrew Sheridan (Sale Sharks & England), Alun Wyn Jones (Ospreys & Wales), Martyn Williams (Cardiff Blues & Wales), Harry Ellis (Leicester Tigers & England), Ronan O'Gara (Munster & Ireland), Shane Williams (Ospreys & Wales)

Referee: Christophe Berdos (France)
Assistant referees: Bryce Lawrence (New Zealand), Vinny Munro (New Zealand)
Television Match Official: Stuart Dickinson (Australia)

View a Printer Friendly version of this Story.

Bookmark or share this story with:

South Africa v Lions (2nd Test) Match Review
Posted by: Lions 2009 (IP Logged)
Date: 29/06/2009 02:46

What do you think? You can have your say by posting below.
If you do not already have an account Click here to Register.

Re: South Africa v Lions (2nd Test) Match Review
Posted by: kiwitaff (IP Logged)
Date: 29/06/2009 08:43

Quote:
Matthew Rees – 6 – Lost a fair number of lineouts due to poor throwing in, two of which proved very costly. Decent ball carrying in the loose.

I only saw us lose 2 lineouts, one of which was Matfield at his best out jumping his opposite number. Rees did also overthrow one that got taken by Jenkins at the tail and one was called not straight (harshly). Overall the lineout was more of a success than last week.

Re: South Africa v Lions (2nd Test) Match Review
Posted by: Patrick (IP Logged)
Date: 29/06/2009 09:00

Two were called not straight, as they very obviously weren't, particularly the first. He was lucky not to have more pinged against him, some others looked very crooked. Two got stolen, and one, nearly two was over-thrown.

We lost 3 last week. One due to Matfield and the other two simply over-thrown.

Re: South Africa v Lions (2nd Test) Match Review
Posted by: Isaac Dix (IP Logged)
Date: 29/06/2009 18:59

A fair number of lineouts were lost ? Funny that? I only remember seeing one not straight and one pinched? Not bad for Rees.(Sm6)
Rees deserves to keep his place for the 3rd test IMO. He is still a better option than Mears or Ford.
Jenkins 6? Hairbear 7? Until the unfortunate happened the front row were magnificent. They dominated the Saffa front row. Melon was more than just secure in the scrum. He clearly had Smit in trouble. Adam Jones stuffed the BEAST and stopped the Saffa crowd chanting. The silence after that was deafening.

I see you gave Sheridan a 7? (Sm79) Is it because the SKY cameras were focused on him all of the time ? Melon and Hairbear had more of an impact and did more damage. Bit unfair I think.

Re: South Africa v Lions (2nd Test) Match Review
Posted by: kiwitaff (IP Logged)
Date: 30/06/2009 08:24

Be fair Isaac, he came about as close as he ever will to saying Mike Phillips isn't actually that bad. To be kind to other Welsh players too may have tipped him over the edge. How Sheridan got a better score than Melon I don't quite get though, was on the pitch less time and didn't have to worry about scrummaging. Thought he played well and carried better than he has in ages but to give him a 7??? that's the same mark as the man who 'was near faultless with the boot and ran the back line superbly. Created the try for Kearney'. You decide!

Re: South Africa v Lions (2nd Test) Match Review
Posted by: Mr lumpy (IP Logged)
Date: 01/07/2009 08:40

Kiwitaff your name says it all when you comment on players other than welsh.

Re: South Africa v Lions (2nd Test) Match Review
Posted by: kiwitaff (IP Logged)
Date: 01/07/2009 08:59

Strange, I haven't commented on any players other than to highlight some strange quirks in Patrick's scores? To me Shaw and Kearney were head and shoulders above the other players on Saturday. I'm just surprised that Sheridan could be marked higher than Jenkins when he made less contribution. Most Welsh supporters will agree that Rees is suspect on the lineout throw although he appears to have improved a lot this season and on Saturday it was no worse than the previous week with Mears (who was my own first choice pick at hooker after being the form player in that position in the warm up matches). The rest of my post is quoting the original comments in the match review.

On the subject of Adam Jones, I said from the start of the tour he should start and took stick from certain people (who will remain nameless) who just used the (Sm22) smiley but couldn't back this up with any sensible comment when challenged. When it comes to the Lions, I'm a Lions supporter and want the strongest team out there to give them the best chance to win and I think the starting 15 on Saturday gave that team.

Re: South Africa v Lions (2nd Test) Match Review
Posted by: Isaac Dix (IP Logged)
Date: 01/07/2009 18:30

Good post. Same opinion. I only want the best XV to start. I thought the front row in the first test deserved their places on merit. No arguments.
Geech had no choice but to change the front row after the first test. I think it was myself that suggested that Jones was in with a reasonable chance of a test start. This was laughed off by a certain poster whose name rhyms with poo.

Goto Thread: PreviousNext
Goto: Message ListLog In

Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.
We record all IP addresses on the Sportnetwork message boards which may be required by the authorities in case of defamatory or abusive comment. We seek to monitor the Message Boards at regular intervals. We do not associate Sportnetwork with any of the comments and do not take responsibility for any statements or opinions expressed on the Message Boards. If you have any cause for concern over any material posted here please let us know as soon as possible by e-mailing abuse@sportnetwork.net