Username
Password
Harlequins 13-13 Cardiff Blues
By AlanQuin November 18 2007
A draw 13-13 against Cardiff Blues in the second round of the Heineken Cup pool is a wholly unsatisfactory result. It was yet another game which Harlequins could and ought to have won and which they had ample opportunities to win. Harlequins started the game with urgency and determination and were immediately exerting pressure in the visitors’ twenty-two.

Indeed, their command of possession and territory was suchthat the visitors did not get out of their own half of the field for overtwenty minutes from the start. Unfortunately, Quins failed to convert that superiority intopoints.  They had only a solitarypenalty from Malone after six minutes to show from their efforts, the fly halfhaving missed with two drop-goal attempts, one of which struck the post, and akickable penalty.  The score camefrom an excellent up and under kick by Malone and good chasing produced thepressure that gained the penalty.

 

Harlequins kept the pressure on their opponents kickinganother penalty for a five metre lineout. A good catch and drive was well defended and ultimately turned overalmost on the line and another chance for a Quins’ score had gone.   Malone had a fine break but therewas no support and he was caught short of the line and the ball turnedover.  Nick Easter retired to theblood bin for the first of two visits, being replaced by Chris Hala’ufia.  Unforced errors on both sides preventedany real width on the greasy ball in the drizzle that persisted during thefirst half.

 

A penalty for Quins going in off their feet, allowed Cardiffto find touch in the Quins’ half and from a penalty conceded at a scrum Blairtook play into the Quins’ twenty-two for the Blues’ first visit in thematch.   But Jim Evans stolethe lineout, as he did on a number of other occasions during the afternoon, andthe danger was cleared.  Ugo Monyedemonstrated his defensive powers, gathering a long kick through, getting backon his feet and staying strong until help arrived. 

 

Then after the first half hour an infringement at a lineoutgave Blair the chance to kick the penalty and level the scores at 3 – 3.   Quins again put pressure on theBlues as Robshaw and Monye chased the restart, caught Shanklin and the ball wasturned over in the ensuing ruck. In an attempt to put some width on the attack the ball was moved quicklyleft, where Monye lurked on the wing and Strettle was looping round in support,but Tani Fuga fumbled the ball and a chance was lost.

 

Both sides continued to provide unnecessary errors toprevent any fluidity of play. A penalty to Cardiff saw the ball not thrown instraight at the subsequent lineout. An offside by Quins saw Cardiff kick deep into the Quins’ twenty-two andyet again Jim Evans stole the throw and Malone cleared.

 

Then Gomarsall put up a high kick, deceiving the Cardiffdefender who made the mistake of letting the ball bounce.  It came down a second time into thehands of Strettle as he sped towards the line, but the defender managed to gethold of a leg and stop the certain try. The ball bobbled about and was knocked into touch by a Cardiffhand. 

 

The half was nearly over as Quins took a lineout only fivemetres from the Cardiff line. Chris Robshaw took the ball and as Jones feinted to loop right, takingsome of the defence with him, the ball was smuggled to Nick Easter who drovestraight through the gap which opened to score a good try without a singledefender having any chance of stopping him.  Malone kicked a fine conversion from the left touchline andQuins went in at half time with a lead of 10 – 3.

 

The second half started with Cardiff attempting to increasethe pace and break out of their own half of the pitch.  A poor pass that went to ground behindthe intended recipient saw Monye, at speed, kick on along the touchlinetwice.  The ball rolled left intotouch depriving the winger of a certain try.  Then after seven minutes Kohn went offside at a ruck andBlair took the opportunity to add three points for Cardiff and the score to 10– 6. At the same time Nick Easter left for a second session under the stitchingneedle in the blood bin.

 

A great kick high and catch by Mike Brown followed by abreak past three defenders was stopped and Cardiff were lucky to get afingertip to deflect the pass for David Strettle saving a certain try andturning defence into attack as a kick deep into Quins territory almost broughtabout a Cardiff score.  A fumbledknock-on gave Quins a scrum and Gomarsall’s box kick cleared the danger.

 

Easter now returned with fresh bandages and when thevisitors went offside at a lineout Malone was able to find touch deep in theCardiff half.  For once Cardiffstole a Quins’ lineout and a high ball saw Ugo Monye claim a mark as he crashedinto the post protective padding. Perhaps the blow affected his judgment because his kick did not findtouch.  Instead Tom James, theBlues wing, ran the ball back fending off the tackle of Robshaw and passinginside to Spice for the scrum half to evade yet another tackle and score a goodtry.  Blair easily added theconversion to give Cardiff a lead of 10 – 13.

 

The lead barely lasted one minute as Martin Williams camethrough offside at a lineout and Malone kicked a difficult 45 metre penalty tolevel the score.  With one halfhour remaining, both sides looked for opportunities to score, but without success.Both fly halves missed with attempted drop goals.   A brilliant catch of his own high ball by Mike Brownfound Paul Volley offside.  Onceagain Cardiff’s lineout throw was not straight.  Another Mike Brown special put Quins on the attack.  Cardiff too had a final attempt to rununtil a forward pass brought it to an end.

 

Quins gradually picked and drove to a position from whichMalone could drop a goal and win the game.  Unfortunately, Gomarsall, as he later acknowledged, made awrong decision to try to gain another few yards and collided with Volley.  The referee adjudged that to beaccidental offside and blew the final whistle.

 

On a note for the record books, I cannot remember anothermatch since substitutes were allowed in which the only substitute used by Quinswas while Nick Easter was having his blood injuries stitched and all of thestarting fifteen finished the match

 

At the press conference following the game, Cardiff were notdispleased with the two points which were an unexpected bonus after thedifficulties they faced in their lineout.   Asked why Harlequins had not looked for a drop goalwhen they were in position to do so. "Gomars has said it should have gone. He's held his hands up,"said Dean Richards, the Harlequins director of rugby. "At the end weshould have just dropped the goal. You couldn't have asked for a betterposition."

 

Richards admitted he was very disappointed that his sidefailed to win a match they dominated in the first half. "We had 70% of thelineout possession, our scrum was pretty good and from a territorial point ofview it was probably 60-40, but we didn't capitalise on it," he said. “Ourremaining four games are all winnable. We shall just have to win them.”

 

Harlequins: M Brown;S Keogh, D Strettle, D W Barry, U Monye; C Malone, A Gomarsall; C Jones, TFuga, M Ross, O Kohn, J Evans, C Robshaw, P Volley (capt), N Easter (CHala'Ufia 15-22 & 46-53).

 

Cardiff: B Blair; TJames, J Robinson, T Shanklin, G Thomas; D Flanagan, J Spice; G Jenkins, T RThomas (G Williams 67) T Filise, D Jones, P Tito (R Sidoli 72), M Molitika, MWilliams, X Rush (capt).

 

Referee: P Gauzere (France).

 

Attendace: 11,340

Bookmark or share this story with:

Goto Thread: PreviousNext
Goto: Message ListNew TopicSearchLog In
Re: Harlequins 13-13 Cardiff Blues
Posted by: Quaking Quin (IP Logged)
Date: 2007:11:19:00:11:13

Good factual report AQ.

You failed to mention Quins perennial problem with the penalty count, which gives away the ball and endlessly destroys momentum - yesterday Quins must have been pinged 15/18 times. The turnover balls lost at key points and the lack of support of the breaking runner (unless you include Volley's offside effort after Brown's excellent up-and-under).


Malone lost it for us. His kicking is simply not up to GP standard. Many said of Jeremy Staunton that it wasn't his fault we were relegated after his final kick. What is undeniable is that it was his fault we lost vital games all season. Deano has to bring back AJ - but again it's hard to see how a ring rusty No.10 will change things in the short term. Deano obviously kept Molly on for the final drop kick (something AJ cannot do) - just a pity Gommars had no faith in him even when under the sticks.

Equally, Deano does not not seem to have the tactical nous - or is it just a tired coaching team. Why-oh-why didn't Quins start the 2nd half with all guns blazing to try to get out of reach instead of giving the opposition the initiative.

Every game is (in Deano's words) 'winnable'. So when is he going to start winning?

Only miracles will keep us in either the EDF or HC - frankly they ain't going to happen.

- We have to beat Ospreys in the EDF by 33 points and not let them gain a bonus point .
- We not only have to win all four remaining HC games but also have to get bonus points in each to progress because we cannot win the pool.

In the league its Gloucester away then Sarries at home - more 'winnerable' games or 'no-hopers' with Deano having lost the pyschological battle.

In reality it's difficulty to see Quins breaking out of a losing cycle when important GP games are dotted between a raft of meaningless cup games.

Now's the chance for Deano to seek inpiration by benchmarking Strettle at No.12, Keogh at Hooker, Ugo as a flanker and Mike Brown at No.10.

Re: Harlequins 13-13 Cardiff Blues
Posted by: Alanquin (IP Logged)
Date: 2007:11:19:08:29:35

I do not like to disagree with you, Malone did not "lose it". True his drop goal attempts, other than the first one which hit the post, were poor. However, much of his tactical kicking was both accurate and correct as options.
The penalty count against Quins was nowhere near as high as you suggest and both sides (and the Sky commentators) found the referee's interpretation of the breakdown difficult to follow.
However, the ref was not the problem. Conditions, two teams trying not to lose, all contributed. Remember, this was the Cardiff team that put over 40 points on Bristol last week in the previous ERC round. The same Bristol that took out Stade Francais yesterday.
Malone has not cost us games in the way Staunton's poor decision making did. Nor for that matter, in the way poor kicking like Paul Challinor in the past did.
Gomarsall's decision is only explicable when you recall Matt Dawson doing the same thing - with more time available - in the 2003 RWC Final. Malone would have had a 35-40 metre DG.
Both teams made unforced errors, both teams turned over ball. Every team does. It is the nature of the game. It would be very boring if they didn't!
(Sm3)

Re: Harlequins 13-13 Cardiff Blues
Posted by: Next of Quin (IP Logged)
Date: 2007:11:19:09:52:31

When we have 60-70% possession, we shouldn't be in the position of pinning our hopes on a last minute drop-goal to win the game. If we could just convert the amount of territory and ball we had, we would have been 15 or so points clear at the end.

Re: Harlequins 13-13 Cardiff Blues
Posted by: The Prof (IP Logged)
Date: 2007:11:19:10:10:42

QQ Mike Brown is actually a pretty good fly half, he played there 3 years ago when Quins U19 won the national cup.

If Stretts thinks he's good at outside centre and the coaches agree with him why not play him there, I don't think the experiment went wrong, the good ball provided by the pack was rather spoiled by the below par performance from the half backs.

PS Ugo has packed down at flanker a fair few times, Simon Keogh has too, although never at hooker smiling smiley

Re: Harlequins 13-13 Cardiff Blues
Posted by: Battering Ram Winger (IP Logged)
Date: 2007:11:19:11:03:38

Quote:
I do not like to disagree with you, Malone did not "lose it". True his drop goal attempts, other than the first one which hit the post, were poor. However, much of his tactical kicking was both accurate and correct as options.

Hang on, he misses twelve points in a close, tight game and didn't lose the match for us?

Re: Harlequins 13-13 Cardiff Blues
Posted by: DOK (IP Logged)
Date: 2007:11:19:11:11:31

Correct! It was a team effort.

Re: Harlequins 13-13 Cardiff Blues
Posted by: Harley Quin (IP Logged)
Date: 2007:11:19:11:19:32

Thanks AlanQuin.

It was more of the same on Saturday. We have no cutting edge. The amount of possession we have should see us win by large margins, but we just cant score tries/points.

Malone's kicking at goal is fast becoming a huge liability for the team. It must also be preying on his mind now. He needs some time out to get his timing back. It is almost a redundant comment to observe that you cannot win at this level without a top 10. We are proving it on a weekly basis.

Top marks to the forwards for really fronting up though. After what Cardiff did to Bristol I was expecting the worst, but it was our forwards who dominated things.

Re: Harlequins 13-13 Cardiff Blues
Posted by: Alanquin (IP Logged)
Date: 2007:11:19:14:03:06

Looking at the entirely missable penalty kick from wide out on the left and at least 45 metres which Malone did kick sucessfully, it could be said that he drew the game for Quins.
To say he missed 12 points is harsh. 6 would be justifiable.
But virtually all kickers miss a couple - even a certain JW

Goto Thread: PreviousNext
Goto: Message ListLog In

Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.
We record all IP addresses on the Sportnetwork message boards which may be required by the authorities in case of defamatory or abusive comment. We seek to monitor the Message Boards at regular intervals. We do not associate Sportnetwork with any of the comments and do not take responsibility for any statements or opinions expressed on the Message Boards. If you have any cause for concern over any material posted here please let us know as soon as possible by e-mailing abuse@sportnetwork.net