rugbyunion
Latest News:

GO GIRL


By Darraghgirl
November 1 2017

  So the first break in the regular season and time for “the cup that nobody cares about” (or wants to sponsor aka the Anglo-Welsh Cup). Yet again this pretty pointless competition with almost unfathomable rules for qualifying for the semi-final drifts into our season. The powers that be decided to replace the Tetley Bitter Cup (which was a proper knock-out tournament with all the romance of “the Cup”, luck of the draw, giant-killing, visits to weird and wonderful non league grounds) with the rather less appealing and somewhat manufactured Anglo-Welsh Cup. It has actually been around since 2005 (when it was the Powergen Cup). It then became the EDF Energy Cup for 3 years before it morphed into the LV Cup. LV stuck with it for 6 years (God help them). It is now sponsorless.  

This Sunday our opponents are Quins (who aren’t actually in our group because our group -3- plays the teams in group 2); which means that in theory a team could qualify for the semi’s without actually winning a game! Crazy. Just for interest-sake, Group 3 consists of ourselves, Northampton Saints (of course but at least we don’t have to play them!), Worcester Warriors and Scarlets. Apart from Quins, we have to play Sale (next week), Dragons and Exeter Chiefs. So get your head round that one.

This competition would make so much more sense if there was something in the rules about encouraging younger/fringe players. Maybe something along the lines of under 23’s or less than 10 first-team appearances (or to encourage the older guys/injury returners maybe less than 3 first-team appearances this season). I’m sure the powers that be could sort something out if they had a mind to. As it is, teams like Sarries treat it as a development competition and play their youngsters. Certain other clubs (ie those who have no other hope of silverware) will put out more-or-less their first team, especially if they get a whiff of success!

By the looks of their Instagram Feeds, most of the first team who aren’t playing for England (or Wales) have gone off to the sunshine for a few days. Last Sunday’s A-team game is likely to provide a guide to this match – a game which on paper Sarries had a strong team but on the pitch, Quins won quite easily. I think I read somewhere that the Storm team will form the majority of the A/W Squad so they will need to step up their game a bit! I think we can discount almost everyone who played last Saturday, with the probable exception of Will Skelton (who needs game time) and Christopher Tolofua (who needs throwing practice – if he’s not with France) and the possible exception of Nathan Earle and Richard Barrington.

So with a few probable tweaks, I think we’ll see something like: 15 Matt Gallagher; 14 Mike Ellery, 13 Rotimi Segun, 12. Dominic Morris, 11 Ali Crossdale; 10 Max Malins, 9 Tom Whiteley; 1 Hayden Thompson-Stringer, 2 Christopher Tolofua, 3 Kieran Longbottom; 4 Will Skelton, 5 Jack Nay; 6 Anthony Maka, 7 Joel Conlon, 8 Ben Earl.

As for Quins – they are all but out of Europe after 2 defeats but sitting 5th in the Premiership. However they have a worrying injury list (look at the number of “guest” players they fielded last weekend – not that it did them any harm!) so will probably not be tempted to risk any first team players. Not having much knowledge of the Quins’ A team, I popped across to the Quins message board for a bit of help. Apart from the suggestion that Yarde should play on his own (!) –sadly no longer an option - the suggested team goes something like this: 15.R Chisholm 14.Alofa Alofa 13.Sloan 12.Lang 11.Waters 10.Swiel 9.Lewis 1.Boyce 2.Elia 3.Swainston/McNulty 4.Glynn/Merrick 5.Okafor/Matthews 6.Lamb 7.White 8.J Chisholm

The RFU often use the Anglo-Welsh Cup as a training ground for referees too and it looks like the officials could also prove very interesting. The man in the middle is Hamish Smales (from what I can see a former England 7’s player who has been officiating in the Championship) assisted by Craig Maxwell-Keys (we know him) and Sara Cox, the first woman referee to be centrally contracted to the RFU and England’s only referee at the Rio Olympics . Go Girl!

View a Printer Friendly version of this Story.

Bookmark or share this story with:

GO GIRL
TheSaracens.com (IP Logged)
01/11/2017 16:11
What do you think? You can have your say by posting below.
If you do not already have an account Click here to Register.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2017:11:15:16:08:32 by Darraghgirl.

 
Re: GO GIRL
Sully08 (IP Logged)
02/11/2017 15:01
Thanks DG. Go Girl!

Last weeks A league warm up game will be a marker but at home, with a few additions that you highlight above, and hopefully our kicking boots on this week we should do better than last Sunday.

Given the extended A-League this season it would seem a good opportunity to return to a true knock out cup that you refer to above rather than this rather inadequate international window filler.

 
Re: GO GIRL
The Bard (IP Logged)
02/11/2017 17:43
I like the AW cup. It's a great opportunity for the academy and fringe players, making it straight knockout would drastically reduce the number of matches. I have advocated for ages that the two competing groups of 4 should be amalgamated to ensure those who progress have to win most of their games. It also guarantees that you don't meet the same teams in the semi!
Is big Joel Kopku(?) fit? I'd expect him and Dave's Coaches in the second row.
Would also expect Nathan Earle on the wing

 
Re: GO GIRL
primavesi (IP Logged)
08/11/2017 16:06
We should all like the AW cup. It takes up space in the calendar while our internationals are away, minimising the number of meaningful games they are out for....

Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.
We record all IP addresses on the Sportnetwork message boards which may be required by the authorities in case of defamatory or abusive comment. We seek to monitor the Message Boards at regular intervals. We do not associate Sportnetwork with any of the comments and do not take responsibility for any statements or opinions expressed on the Message Boards. If you have any cause for concern over any material posted here please let us know as soon as possible by e-mailing abuse@sportnetwork.net
 

Saracens Poll

How many of our Lions will play in the double header?

See results > Submit >>