Latest News:

Have we blown it?


November 29 2016

Yorkshire Carnegie beat Richmond 39-31 at the RAG under floodlights last Friday evening The lads scored seven tries in the bonus point win  to maintain a twelve point gap over third placed Ealing in the Championship table. So everything is going to plan right?

The previous week we beat fourth placed Doncaster Knights, preventing them scoring a try. That  performance was deemed to be  the required standard of defence for a team sitting in second place in the table. So when we raced into a 22-0 lead at Richmond it was not unreasonable to think that Bryan Redpath had sorted out the defensive frailties of his squad and that they were on track to mount a seriuos challenge to London Irish at the business end of the season. The middle forty minutes at the RAG, when we shipped thirty-one unanswered points, showed that our head coach is no nearer to producing a balanced performance from his players than he was back at the start of the season in September.

In the last few games( some say more than that) our pivotal stand-off has suffered a slump in form. This was illustrated under the Richmond lights when he only managed to kick two goals from seven attempts. Fortunately we have a decent backup 10 in Warren Seals. I should say had a 10 as he has been loaned back to Darlington MP for some reason that is not clear to me. The club have stated he is there to get game time. I would have thought that  he could get meaningful match practice in our 1st XV at the moment.

On Friday night we play Bedford Blues at Headingley Carnegie. Like us Bedford are not having a great season. The difference being that the Blues have only won three out of their ten games whereas we have won nine. Despite losing six games more than us the Blues have conceded sixteen points less than us. We continue to rely on our offence to outgun the opposition. Whilst this can be entertaining it is hardly an ideal strategy for mounting a sustainable assault on the Premiership.

The Bedford game marks the halfway point in the regular season. It is not unreasonable for the fans to expect to see, at this stage of the season, performances that could give us reason to believe that we are on the right track. The progress made since Redpath took over the reins is, in my opinion, minimal. OK so we are second in the league but we are actually further away from the Premiership than when we were competing against Bristol last season.

I expect us to beat Bedford. Our back three have the wide open spaces of HC to work in. Our pack is immense. A ten try thriller beckons. Tykes to win  by 40-28 or something in that region.


C'mon Tykes

View a Printer Friendly version of this Story.

Bookmark or share this story with:
Have we blown it? (IP Logged)
29/11/2016 10:40
What do you think? You can have your say by posting below.
If you do not already have an account Click here to Register.

Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2016:12:16:18:13:36 by Wildwillie .

bird lover
Re: Have we blown it?
bird lover (IP Logged)
29/11/2016 15:44
LETS hope so W|W good honest report. COYC !!!!

Re: Have we blown it?
SouthStandTerracer (IP Logged)
29/11/2016 16:26
Excellent article WW.

Re: Have we blown it?
almostatyke (IP Logged)
29/11/2016 21:57
Nice one WW. In answer to your thread title IMHO the answer in "no". With 9 wins out of 10, I think we will avoid relegation.

Re: Have we blown it?
Albert Fishwick (IP Logged)
02/12/2016 23:29
Nearly blew it tonight alright. Shambles not finishing the game off when ahead - again. McColl looks a pale shadow of the bloke we sent to Gloucester. Pack variable but Buzz needs to be at 8 for as many minutes as possible. Cusack could do with a sack truck to get him around.

Mayhews good, centres ok, Stegman getting there, 9s tolerable. Get Jonah at FB and find someone who can give Ford a run for his money.

Just my two penn'orth, of course.

If I had all the money I've spent on drink ..... I'd spend it on drink.

Re: Have we blown it?
JDH (IP Logged)
02/12/2016 23:54
About right that Al

Re: Have we blown it?
leemingtyke (IP Logged)
03/12/2016 08:59
Yep, I'd agree with that Albert.

I thought Ross Graham looked very promising at hooker and the two homegrown lads on their 100th appearances both played very well. As they always do imho

John R
Re: Have we blown it?
John R (IP Logged)
03/12/2016 15:35

Couldn't agree more!

Spot on with your assessment, I see no need to add to that, other than that I am afraid Joe Ford did little to enhance his reputation by serving up another inept 80 minutes of missing tackles, aimlessly kicking upfield to give Bedford the opportunity to create mayhem and missing penalties! (Was it two or three relatively easy kicks missed.........................again!)

Whom would Brian Redpath replace him with, to rest him for a game or two?

Up the Yorkshire Carnegie TYKES !

bird lover
Re: Have we blown it?
bird lover (IP Logged)
04/12/2016 08:11
He could move Davies to ten ? But he can't tackle and his goal kicking performance at Esher was woeful. Bring back Seals !!!! And put Captain back at 8 Don't understand that at all ??? COYC !!!!!

bird lover
Re: Have we blown it?
bird lover (IP Logged)
04/12/2016 14:02
Ealing sorry. COYC !!!!

North needs success
Re: Have we blown it?
04/12/2016 14:11
Not sure we should be getting on Joe's back to be honest. To me he looked like a much improved player when he came back from Sale. He's just gone off the boil recently but I think he will get it back. He needs encouragement. Goal kicking is a confidence thing. Let's give him a boost by backing him rather than getting on his back.
We Stevie on the other hand is more of a concern. Not worth his place even though he's most likely one of our highest paid players. Should never have let CG go, potentially one of best full backs in league but can't blame him for wanting out when not given a chance. Seb still to fully convince but Jonah excellent this year for me along with Lucock and Davies.

Re: Have we blown it?
yeldor (IP Logged)
04/12/2016 14:12
Whatever our frustrations at the teams efforts I comfort myself in the fact that we are not Bristol supporters. They are having a mare of a season. Takes a very loyal supporter to suffer what they are going through.

sent off carried off never backed off

This Thread has been closed
We record all IP addresses on the Sportnetwork message boards which may be required by the authorities in case of defamatory or abusive comment. We seek to monitor the Message Boards at regular intervals. We do not associate Sportnetwork with any of the comments and do not take responsibility for any statements or opinions expressed on the Message Boards. If you have any cause for concern over any material posted here please let us know as soon as possible by e-mailing

Yorkshire Carnegie Poll

How will we do this coming season

See results > Submit >>