Latest News:

A Trail down the M1

Skipper fit?

By ww
November 9 2017

The Championship fixtures resume this weekend with a full programme. Yorkshire Carnegie follows a familiar route down the M1 to west London and will be hoping to improve on the two defeats suffered the capital so far this season. 

Ealing Trailfinders, this week's opponents, have had a meteoric rise up the Championship and currently sit second in the table with only one defeat against the leading team, Bristol. The club invested heavily in the close- season and it has paid dividends. Howevr some people have questioned the wisdom of such expenditure given that only one club will get promotion this season and all the indications are that it will not be Ealing.

The Carnegie board has, wisely in my opinion, decided that fiscal prudence will prevail this season. The books will balance, come what may. To this end three players have already moved on to ease the financial burden.

Despite these measures our team has already beaten three of the top five clubs. The next two games will determine whether or not it can turn this into a nap hand. In our last game, against a very good Bedford side, the lads showed that they can improve on sixth place in the league. Despite hanging on at the end they never looked like losing the game and scored one of the best tries so far this season.

The side against Ealing will improve with the return of Buckle at hooker. One observer noted that Mayhew could not hit his jumpers at key times against Bedford. Buckle has had two weeks since Mayhew's departure to get it right on the training ground. Our new props, Thomas & Miller-Mills have both been good signings and have taken the pressure off the regulars. Behind them the good form of Sanderson & Whetton (that run, that off-load) coupled with the return of Beck and West gives us plenty of options. For me, this season, our stand out forward has been Ollie Stedman who is proving a worthy successor to Buzz.

Our game will improve if either Davies or Irvine is fit. Lucock has done well as a stand-in but his best position is at 12 where I hope that he will start his 100th league game. Against Bedford Elder showed what a dangerous runner he is . Along with McColl in our back three he will keep the home defence busy at the weekend.

Vallis Way has an artificial pitch. Will this be a factor in who wins the game? Probably! More importantly, for me, is which kicker is on better form as I think that it will be a close run thing. If we have a regular 10 (Davies or Irvine) then I think we have enough to snatch a close game. Carnegie  to win by 3 and bring 4 points back up the M1.

View a Printer Friendly version of this Story.

Bookmark or share this story with:
A Trail down the M1 (IP Logged)
10/11/2017 08:10
What do you think? You can have your say by posting below.
If you do not already have an account Click here to Register.

Edited 2 time(s). Last edit at 2017:11:19:08:30:12 by Wildwillie .

Re: A Trail down the M1
Wildwillie (IP Logged)
10/11/2017 11:47
The team is:

15. Stevie McColl
14. George Watkins
13. Andy Forsyth
12. Tom Casson
11. Chris Elder
10. Pete Lucock
9. Will Homer
1. Marc Thomas
2. Joe Buckle
3. Elliot Millar-Mills
4. Jack Whetton
5. Mike Myerscough
6. Richard Beck
7. Richard Mayhew (c)
8. Ollie Stedman

16. Harry Newborn
17. Charlie Beech
18. James Thraves
19. Ben West
20. Josh Bainbridge
21. Louis Brown
22. Ollie Fox

Re: A Trail down the M1
almostatyke (IP Logged)
10/11/2017 20:12
I note that Max (still available for Carnegie) Green is currently playing (really well) for Bath in the Anglo-Welsh Cup. Jonah Holmes has scored a try for Leicester and we may also recall Claire Daniels who is running the line.

Selby Kev
Re: A Trail down the M1
Selby Kev (IP Logged)
11/11/2017 14:44
Wishing the lads luck...down at my old patch....50 yrs ago!

Just need to use our heads...and heads...and heads....and Stevie's boot. Everything is nothing without territory?

It would be a great 'lead in' to Bristol game if we can take 5 and go 3rd!!

Bringing rugby back to Yorkshire......Come on ye Tykes!!!!!!!!!

Re: A Trail down the M1
JDH (IP Logged)
11/11/2017 17:59
Listening to Jimmy's post match he is pretty upset. Lots of mistakes at key times due to poor execution of simple skills.
Lucock injured now. Casson played 10 second half. Mayhew off with his foot again.
Don't look good for Friday.

There's not spending money and being sensible and then there where we are now. Club need to draft some players in on short Loans .

Re: A Trail down the M1
headingleytyke (IP Logged)
11/11/2017 18:10
We have players who have not not been seen this season. There is a rather large prop who's wages we are paying and still not appeared. Has he been loaned out.
I understand the consolidation this season but not at the situation of looking second rate.

Re: A Trail down the M1
Scuffer (IP Logged)
11/11/2017 18:21
I fear for us against Bristol if, as Jimmy says, we have to draft in academy players and rely on being energetic! It all sounds a bit desperate.

Re: A Trail down the M1
JDH (IP Logged)
11/11/2017 18:25
I doubt cusack could play 10... think he's still injured anyway.
I understand the low funding but I find it hard to stomach. Especially when there guys playing out if position in key areas. Your chances are halved before you kick off.

Could young Harry Davey step up v bris? Anyone seen him much on loan?

Forsyth guilty again of poor handling. At ilkley and v Bedford he was the same poor choices and execution. I don't rate him.

Re: A Trail down the M1
JDH (IP Logged)
11/11/2017 18:28
With all these injuries it's certainly turned that way.

Re: A Trail down the M1
almostatyke (IP Logged)
11/11/2017 19:26
We were essentially playing "Bristol Lite" today on their own (horrible artificial) pitch. The aforementioned pitch is unforgiving to injuries, which has also taken its toll.

Next week we are at home and hopefully Jimmy can motivate a make-do-and-mend squad to perform to the required standard.

Re: A Trail down the M1
Madtyke (IP Logged)
11/11/2017 21:15
The Buddha apparently has a neck injury and was seen in the player's box in the back of the Carnegie stand at the Bedford game. Don't understand the reason for signinghim in the first place, hasn't pulled his weight since arriving back.
As for Carnegie, they're in wind down to becoming a part-time side with little or no ambition to progress due to lack of funding. Either that or complete meltdown with the Club disbanding. Sad really as I have followed them for 20+ years.


Re: A Trail down the M1
JDH (IP Logged)
12/11/2017 00:12
Still could be worse. Look at poor Rotherham.

Re: A Trail down the M1
JDH (IP Logged)
14/11/2017 22:41
Jesus the highlights show the defence was a poor show.
Who's look forward to Friday?!.......

Re: A Trail down the M1
Albert Fishwick (IP Logged)
15/11/2017 07:58
Probably not the burger van. Must be slim pickings these days.

If I had all the money I've spent on drink ..... I'd spend it on drink.

Re: A Trail down the M1
JDH (IP Logged)
15/11/2017 09:12
Get yourself in the cafe bar for some meal pie. Very tasty.

Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.
We record all IP addresses on the Sportnetwork message boards which may be required by the authorities in case of defamatory or abusive comment. We seek to monitor the Message Boards at regular intervals. We do not associate Sportnetwork with any of the comments and do not take responsibility for any statements or opinions expressed on the Message Boards. If you have any cause for concern over any material posted here please let us know as soon as possible by e-mailing

Yorkshire Carnegie Poll

How will the 18/19 season turn out?

See results > Submit >>