Latest news:

Saturday's officials
Discussion started by GlawsyD , 03 September, 2020 14:50
Saturday's officials
GlawsyD 03 September, 2020 14:50
Gloucester v London Irish
@ Kingsholm
Referee: Hamish Smales
Assistant referees: Simon Harding, Phil Watters
TMO: David Rose

Re: Saturday's officials
SixNineOne 03 September, 2020 16:24
Thatís a pretty inexperienced line up. Letís hope for both teamsí sake that he puts in a better performance than Ian Tempest and doesnít niggle the game to death.

Re: Saturday's officials
franciscorrigan 03 September, 2020 16:30
I know you have to start your Premiership Rugby career as a ref somewhere, but why us? Have they decided that games for the "lesser" sides have little or no bearing on the league standings and they can use these games as learning experience? It will be very interesting to see Smales' style of reffing. I just hope he's not another Tempest, but a younger JPD(Sm63)

Re: Saturday's officials
SixNineOne 03 September, 2020 16:52
Itís interesting that they put Smales with a couple of inexperienced ARs. Iíd have expected a more experienced head running the line to provide a bit of support to a debutant. I was also surprised to see that this weekend Ian Tempest will be refereeing his 72nd GP match and Tom Foley doing his 80th. I used to think Foley was a bit unreliable but Iím happy to admit that he has improved significantly over the last couple of seasons. Iím just disappointed that Ian Tempest has signally failed to improve despite a near equivalent number of games...

Re: Saturday's officials
M51 03 September, 2020 18:58
If only the RFU would give Wayne Barnes ( or somebody with similair knowledge ) the job of retraining the likes of Tempest and Co on scrum management. Not sending props off when the scrum is serially failing, just give the penalty try and move on. How on earth does Ian T think the next scrum will be any better if the other team have got scrum dominance (it beggars belief) and the replacement prop is even less experienced. Rant over.

Re: Saturday's officials
franciscorrigan 03 September, 2020 19:53
What most referees seem to forget is that there is nothing illegal in being pushed backwards, as long as you stay down and keep your bind. Too many penalties are given erroniously and prematurely. it would be good to see that once the ball gets to the feet of the 8, the ref says "Use It", if nothing illegal has occurred. Too many sides milking penalties, then the kick to the corner and the inevitable catch and drive, It's so boring. If there were fewer scrum penalties, perhaps we might see some skillful forwards, rather than the huge, slow, behemoths that seem to populate some front rows.(Sm63)


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.
We record all IP addresses on the Sportnetwork message boards which may be required by the authorities in case of defamatory or abusive comment. We seek to monitor the Message Boards at regular intervals. We do not associate Sportnetwork with any of the comments and do not take responsibility for any statements or opinions expressed on the Message Boards. If you have any cause for concern over any material posted here please let us know as soon as possible by e-mailing abuse@sportnetwork.net