Latest News:

A Tale of Two Budgets?

By Shawshank
October 19 2018

For the try-soaked London Irish fans it was the best of times. But for the few brave Yorkies at the Madstad it was the worst of times, when their team was pretty much dismantled in every facet of the game by an impressive Irish team displaying a ruthlessness that was seldom evident in our last visit to the Championship two seasons ago.    

Four first half tries gave LI a comfortable 31-0 lead at half time, and in the second half a gluttonous Irish  side rattled up an astonishing 8 further tries, to leave a final score of London Irish 72 Yorkshire Carnegie 5.

A posting on the Yorks MB earlier this week stated that their playing budget for this season was £1M. At a guess the LI playing budget is going to be at least £3m, and probably quite some more. It would be easy to simply conclude that this massive disparity explains this lop-sided result, and that if/when we get promoted we will suffer similarly against the better-resourced squad of the other 11 GP teams.

However, I think that were enough encouraging signs from yesterday to believe that we may be in the process of building a squad far more capable of standing up for itself next season, despite likely budget imbalances.

For starters we now seem to have a number of destructive ball-carriers in the pack, which was one of the most glaring problems from last season. As well as Matt Rogerson and Capt. Josh, Big Barney Maddison impressed yesterday with some great charges, and it was also fantastic to see Danny H-A back in action and looking full of aggression. Olly Hoskins celebrated his 50th LI cap with a hat-trick and also featured strongly in the loose.

OK, maybe the Yorkie’s defence was not up to much, but they did continue to dog it out bravely, and it  was all so much more dynamic from LI than for the last 3 seasons.

Another promising sign was the better and more incisive play of the backs – Ben Meehan was a livewire as an emergency at fly-half (did anyone see Smyler getting injured in the warm-ups?), although it’s clear that if he is to play at 10 in important games we need a proper kicker on the pitch. Tom Parton continued to show  skill and pace at 15 – he really does look the real deal.

I also thought Brendan Macken had an outstanding game at 13 -  he looked quick and powerful and made some great breaks, and  the backs appeared to be really  gelling as a unit. A few times early in the second half especially however I felt that the ball should have been released to them sooner, rather than going for the repeated pick-and-drives - both Ben Loader and Topsy being  under-used considering the comfortable score line at the time.

So, plenty of encouragement. And with a number of our top players still to feature eg. Nalaga, Bell, Coman and Gilsenan, we can surely hope for more results like this over the coming weeks.


View a Printer Friendly version of this Story.

Bookmark or share this story with:

A Tale of Two Budgets?
The Craic (IP Logged)
19/10/2018 10:13
What do you think? You can have your say by posting below.
If you do not already have an account Click here to Register.

Re: A Tale of Two Budgets?
PV (IP Logged)
21/10/2018 08:56
Thanks for doing this SS. Good read, sad to see Yorkshire struggling so badly on the finances though.

Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.
We record all IP addresses on the Sportnetwork message boards which may be required by the authorities in case of defamatory or abusive comment. We seek to monitor the Message Boards at regular intervals. We do not associate Sportnetwork with any of the comments and do not take responsibility for any statements or opinions expressed on the Message Boards. If you have any cause for concern over any material posted here please let us know as soon as possible by e-mailing

London Irish Poll

What do you think of this poll?

See results > Submit >>