Username
Password
A Cup Too Far? Cardiff Blues 23-12 Harlequins
By AlanQuin
January 13 2008
Harlequins are still searching for their first win in the Heineken Cup since they defeated Bridgend in 2002. They have managed drawn games against Cardiff twice and Castres but victory has eluded them. At Cardiff Arms Park last night they were beaten by a side that dominated the game from the start and might well have won by a greater margin.

A series of pitch inspections were necessary during a day of torrential rain that had placed the match in considerable doubt before the weather relented and allowed the standing water to drain away.  The surface was still treacherous and very muddy but the match could be played.

The home side had the most to gain from this game. Victory would set up a qualification decider next week against Bristol and, hopefully, lead them into the quarter-finals of the competition.  They set out with considerable determination attacking through many phases and when they gained a penalty for offside choosing to find touch for an attacking lineout.  The pressure and willingness to move the ball quickly almost brought a try but the crossing obstruction which had allowed the gap was instantly penalised by the referee, the whistle blowing even before the Cardiff centre had crossed the line.

It took about ten minutes before Quins were able to mount any attack and then it ended with Luscombe bundled into touch still fifteen metres from the Cardiff line. But then Quins were pushed back again and forced to defend strongly close to their own line. Inevitably they conceded a penalty and this time Blair kicked for goal and duly opened the scoring.  Thus encouraged, Cardiff resumed the attack, exerting very considerable pressure and only good defence close to their own line kept Quins from conceding another score.

Quins were now getting back into the game and might have been better place had two penalties been kicked successfully.  Unfortunately, Malone appears to have little confidence in his kicking and, despite the wind behind him, both kicks drifted wide to the right.

Then from a lineout outside the twenty-two the ball was passed swiftly left to find their centre, Dafydd Hewitt cutting a line between Malone and Barry and crossing untouched under the posts.  Blair added the simple conversion.  Half-time followed shortly and Cardiff led 10 – 0.

Quins came out with greater determination in the second half and began to pressurise the Blues into unforced handling errors.  Eventually, after some ten minutes, the ball came out from a ruck in the Cardiff twenty-two and So’oialo passed quickly to Malone.  The latter’s long miss pass found Mike Brown who beat two tacklers and put Hal Luscombe in for the try in the corner.  Malone kicked the most difficult of his three attempts and added the points for 10 – 7.

Quins were now well back in the match.  The forwards continued to do good work and had not really been troubled in scrum or lineout. But within the next ten minutes two disciplinary errors cost Quins dear. First Hala’Ufia was adjudged to have come in at the side of a ruck. Then a high tackle by De Wet Barry on McLeod saw the centre shown the yellow card.  Both offences were punished by successful penalty kicks from Blair, widening the score gap to 16 – 7 after eighteen minutes of the second half.

Quins continued to try hard and there were good things from Tom Guest and Tom Williams, but despite the pressure created Cardiff were able to turn over ball and resume attack.  With ten minutes or so remaining a quadruple substitution failed to create any improvement.  Indeed, the opposite was the case as excellent work by the Cardiff forwards saw Shanklin driven over for the try that sealed the game.  Blair converted and the lead increased to 23 – 7.

Quins did not give up and came back at their opponents.  From a breakdown in the Cardiff twenty-two Jarvis moved the ball right towards a two man overlap and found Mike Brown.  The full back evaded the would-be tackler and scored the try.  Jarvis’ kick missed leaving a full time score of 23 – 12.

Quins supporters will be disappointed at yet another loss but there were many good things to be taken from the performance.  The forwards worked tirelessly and effectively and both Ceri Jones and Mike Ross tackled ferociously all night.  So’oialo, too, worked hard to direct the forward effort and to provide decent ball to the backs. Under the rain of high balls Mike Brown was sure and fearless and was instrumental in both tries.  Luscombe, too, had a good game.  The basic problem is the loss of form of Malone at fly half.  Jarvis is no better.

That is reflected in Dean Richards’ comments after the game when praised the performance of the front row but bemoaned the lack of game control.  Nevertheless, as a performance it was a substantial improvement over the previous outing against Leicester.

Blues: Ben Blair; Jamie Roberts, Tom Shanklin, Dafydd Hewitt, Gareth Thomas; Nick Macleod, Jason Spice; Gethin Jenkins, Gareth Williams, Tauf'au Filise, Deiniol Jones, Paul Tito, Maama Molitika, Martyn Williams, Xavier Rush (capt).
Replacements: John Yapp, Duane Goodfield for G. Williams (76), Scott Morgan, Mark Lewis, Richie Rees, Rhys Jones, Jamie Robinson for D. Hewitt (77). 

Harlequins: Mike Brown; David Strettle, Hal Luscombe, De Wet Barry, Tom Williams; Chris Malone, Steve So'oialo; Ceri Jones, Gary Botha, Mike Ross, James Percival, Nicolas Spanghero, Tom Guest, Paul Volley (capt), Chris Hala'ufia
Replacements: Tani Fuga for Botha (70), Ricky Nebbett, Ollie Kohn for Percival (70), Phil Davies for Hala'ufia (70), Danny Care, Adrian Jarvis for Malone (70), Tosh Masson for Barry (70). 

Sin Bin: Barry (58).

Attendance: 9,716 

Referee: Romain Poite (France)

View a Printer Friendly version of this Story.

Bookmark or share this story with:

A Cup Too Far? Cardiff Blues 23-12 Harlequins
Posted by: ComeAllWithin.co.uk (IP Logged)
Date: 13/01/2008 19:10

A Cup Too Far? Cardiff Blues 23-12 Harlequins

Re: A Cup Too Far? Cardiff Blues 23-12 Harlequins
Posted by: The Prof (IP Logged)
Date: 13/01/2008 19:11

Thank for the report Alan, as you say it was a much improved performance and the pack performed very well again

Re: A Cup Too Far? Cardiff Blues 23-12 Harlequins
Posted by: squin (IP Logged)
Date: 13/01/2008 20:20

Some individuals (Jones, Ross and Guest) performed well in the pack but as a whole I do not think you can say they performed very well again. We have plenty of problems in the backs around 10 - 12 - 13 but these are not helped by the pitifully slow ball that the pack win. That is when they decide to release the ball out to the backs and don't decide to keep the ball among themselves passing to static runners

Re: A Cup Too Far? Cardiff Blues 23-12 Harlequins
Posted by: Harley Quin (IP Logged)
Date: 13/01/2008 20:38

Thanks Alan.

I thought the front row was superb, and a few others had decent games. However, generally, we were high on defensive effort, low on offensive prowess - yet again! The 10/12 axis is awful at the moment.

Re: A Cup Too Far? Cardiff Blues 23-12 Harlequins
Posted by: kevin (IP Logged)
Date: 13/01/2008 21:37

I genuinely find it difficult to find any of the superlatives for the front row albeit it did work hard and throughout. But just as we have a lack, total lack, of ingenuity in the backs it has to be said that forwards pressure just short of the tryline does not seem to yield us any points either. Let me reiterate, the front row worked hard but the 'efectiveness' is debateable. We used to have the semblance of a good rolling maul but that seems to have gone array.

Re: A Cup Too Far? Cardiff Blues 23-12 Harlequins
Posted by: Quaking Quin (IP Logged)
Date: 13/01/2008 23:47

Other teams have worked us out and there is nothing else in the locker.

Re: A Cup Too Far? Cardiff Blues 23-12 Harlequins
Posted by: Harley Quin (IP Logged)
Date: 14/01/2008 11:49

kevin,

The reason I thought the front row was suberb was, admittedly, from a defensive standpoint. Within a very short space of time in the second half, both Mike and Ceri produced tackles of great courage and commitment. It made me proud. Generally, I thought the front row had a great game, considering the pressure being applied by a rampant Cardiff team.

Perhaps I am wrong, but I do not look for props to be "offensive juggernauts". Hence, I thought they were superb.(Sm13)

Re: A Cup Too Far? Cardiff Blues 23-12 Harlequins
Posted by: Alanquin (IP Logged)
Date: 14/01/2008 12:26

The problem is still in midfield. Early in the season Malone was playing well. He made tries and scored some. True, he missed kicks and that has continued. But on Friday, he got the most difficult one, a conversion from the touchline! Unfortunately, he has lost form and confidence. The two go together. The centre combinations have not been working although Luscombe had a good game on Friday. I am sure that the coaches are working on the problem. I am not sure how you reinstill the necessary confidence in a player like Malone. That is what is needed.
The problem is compounded because Jarvis's form is not great and Jewell lacks experience and is not that good a kicker.
The pack is playing well but are too inclined to resort to "pick and drive" around the fringes and eventually knock on or turn over possession because they are continuing too long.
I am sure that the problem is being worked on, but the cure may take a little time.

Re: A Cup Too Far? Cardiff Blues 23-12 Harlequins
Posted by: Teddington Taff (IP Logged)
Date: 14/01/2008 12:40

Xavier Rush and Martin Williams were phenomenal for Cardiff. That our younger and less experienced back line players held them in check for so long is a credit to them. Though I did not include Volley in this his experience is - week in and week out - obviously helping them enormously. Tom Guest had a great game and the Huff worked tirelessly throughout.

Re: A Cup Too Far? Cardiff Blues 23-12 Harlequins
Posted by: kevin (IP Logged)
Date: 14/01/2008 12:54

cri and ross were, defensively very good. it is a disappointment that ceri is not looking as dangerous on the oppo 5m line as he once was. Tom Guest is a fantastic prospect.

Re: A Cup Too Far? Cardiff Blues 23-12 Harlequins
Posted by: Chiggs (IP Logged)
Date: 14/01/2008 13:17

Quaking Quin - Well put.
Quins are so one dimensional - I'd even say boring to watch at present.Others teams have sussed us and know how to defend on the whole. It's all well and good saying the pack performed very well(which they did) but largely what did we create? It was often very slow ball and Cardiff were waiting.
This rolling maul also seems to be unafective.

Re: A Cup Too Far? Cardiff Blues 23-12 Harlequins
Posted by: Harlequin Dave (IP Logged)
Date: 14/01/2008 13:41

Having spent over 3 hours getting to the game, I was under no delusion that we would win, but hoped for improvements after the Leicester implusion. Overall whilst always looking second best, we played with heart and commitment. We know there are issues in midfiled, but despite this i felt we played much better. If confidence was higher in the kicking stakes, and we were not robbed of a perfectly good Stret's try we might have even won! (albeit not being the better side).

Obviously, we need to see improvements in the centre's, and that where we as supporters need to think, "how can we help", what can we do to build the confidence of "our" team, rather than do the opposite.

Having spoken to one of the players after the Leicester game, it is clear that they read the boards, and can and are affected by what we say about them!

As Mad Max would say, lets get behind the team, (and I do not mean by that pretending they are brill, we know their not, ....yet!)

Come on you Quins!!!!

Re: A Cup Too Far? Cardiff Blues 23-12 Harlequins
Posted by: Harley Quin (IP Logged)
Date: 14/01/2008 13:56

I know people at the Club read what is said on this website.

That is why I made the plea a couple of weeks ago under the thread "This site in 2008". I want them to continue to read it. That way we get a chance to get our points across.

Re: A Cup Too Far? Cardiff Blues 23-12 Harlequins
Posted by: The Prof (IP Logged)
Date: 14/01/2008 14:48

Harlequin Dave, were you sitting in the back row of the emptier stand (I can't remember what it was called), if so I think I might have been beside you, if so it was nice to meet you. I have a very similar opinion of the game to you, perhaps it looked better in the flesh than watching it on telly.

Guest certainly looked a handful, it would be good to see him play more regularly, having him in a back row with Skinner and Robshaw would certainly scare some others with their pace, it's pretty much impossible to leave Easter out though and Volley's dark arts on the ground are certainly very useful too.

Re: A Cup Too Far? Cardiff Blues 23-12 Harlequins
Posted by: barquin mad (IP Logged)
Date: 14/01/2008 15:32

Much has been said about Paul Volley, but we always look a better team when he is in the starting line-up.

Three players stood out for me on Friday; Ceri and Ross, but the one who most impressed me was James Percival.

Having spent much of the weekend lazing in front of the tv, what screamed out to me was that the more successful teams have a scrum half who keeps the defence guessing, always prepared to look for gaps. We have problems at 10, 12 and 13, but to me the problem emantes a bit closer to the pack.

Re: A Cup Too Far? Cardiff Blues 23-12 Harlequins
Posted by: Harlequin Dave (IP Logged)
Date: 14/01/2008 17:40

Prof, Yeah I was there in block 11 right at the top (with partner), and was one of probably only half a dozen trying to get our voices heard ("Harlequins"), despite the cold. Good to meet you, no doubt we will catch up again.

As you say seeing the game in the flesh is different to watching on the box (which of course I did on Saturday). Again wholly agree with your comments re Guest / Robshaw / Skinner, who are clearly players who make the future look bright. Just need some pitch time, and gaining of the "black arts" from Volley.

Also agree with barquin mad re Percival.

If we can get the midfield working more effectively the forwards, who in the past have come in for much critism (which is not the case this year) will have the confidence to get the ball to the backs, who clearly have talent. Mike Brown showed that he get get past defences, when given early ball, and we know what Strets can do if given the ball when in space!

We showed in the early games and against Glos that we have players that can play, but at the moment some (too many) have lost form / confidence, I am sure Deano and the coaches are working on that, and hopefully Quins fans will do the same (maybe even stay to the end of a game, .. what does it do to their confidence when their fans start leaving in numbers before the end?), equally the team need to show their appreciation to the fans after the game (I for one sometimes feel that they don't do enough)

What ever happens, once a Quin always a Quin!

Goto Thread: PreviousNext
Goto: Message ListLog In

Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.
We record all IP addresses on the Sportnetwork message boards which may be required by the authorities in case of defamatory or abusive comment. We seek to monitor the Message Boards at regular intervals. We do not associate Sportnetwork with any of the comments and do not take responsibility for any statements or opinions expressed on the Message Boards. If you have any cause for concern over any material posted here please let us know as soon as possible by e-mailing abuse@sportnetwork.net
 

Harlequins Poll

Who was man of the match against Worcester Warriors?