Username
Password
Harlquins 27-28 London Irish
By DOK September 28 2008
Could Have Won It, Should Have Won It, Didn’t Win It! The day was sunny and bright; it was warm enough to be in shirtsleeves (and for some hardy souls shorts!). I was quietly confident that despite the fact they’d push us hard, we were going to get a win, and a good win, over London Irish!

It didn’t look promising. After the opening exchanges, Irish got a penalty and their full back Peter Hewat slotted it over. Before we’d even got into the game we were 0-3 in the first minute!

Moments later Harlequins were awarded a penalty in a reasonably kickable position. Reasonably kickable for anyone but Malone, as the Molly Disappreciation Society (MDS) around me were quick to point out. But, no, wonders of wonders he kicked a good three pointer (although it shaved the right post more than I’d have liked). 3-3 after five minutes.

Seven minutes into the game Tom Guest won a line out ball, Malone released David Strettle who made a huge run upfield, avoiding at least four attempts to tackle him and showing his strength as well as his guile. He was brought down short of the line but the ball was recycled and Malone did a nice miss pass to Ugo who powered over for a try! Uuuuugoooo!

Unfortunately this was more or less on the Lexus touch line (or is it back to The West Stand touch line?). Anyway, the kick was from there and the MDS were convinced this was a waste of time. Molly fooled us all by kicking a beautiful conversion. 7 minutes into the game and we’re 10-3 up against Irish, who would have thought?

There follows 10 minutes of to-ing and fro-ing and kicks up and kicks down. It’s clear Irish’s vaunted line out is broken. Minty puts himself about and is everywhere. After a particularly bruising charge, he has to stop with bruised ribs by the look of it. We’re winning the breakdowns and Irish can’t string three passes together without dropping it. Please let it continue!

Just when I’m convinced that Dean Richards (the ref) is going to give us nothing despite all the help the Lexus has been offering, he pings Irish for not rolling away. Up steps Molly and its 13-3 and not even 20 minutes gone.

On the 25th minute Tom Guest starts the move, which results in his try. He gets the ball over half way, Malone and Care keep the ball alive and he scores a beautiful try from a well-worked overlap. Malone by now is well in the groove and sinks the conversion no problem. 20-3 and not even half time.

Just after this Andy Gomarsall and Tani start warming up just in front of the West Stand, so we treat Tani to a chorus of “One F in Fuga, there’s only one F in Fuga!” Andy Gomarsall is highly amused and Tani’s shoulders can be seen shaking, but he doesn’t acknowledge us!

There’s some more up and down the field stuff, but we look comfortable. Irish’s line out still isn’t firing. Peter Richards is getting stick from the crowd and knocks on. We even see that rarest of beasts a rolling maul for a brief time.

Then there’s an innocuous looking line out on half way. The ball goes back Irish’s way, Peter Hewat puts boot to ball and it bounces through our line, a clever kick to Delon Armitage and a try to Irish. Was he offside? I couldn’t see but a number of people round me thought so. Anyway, conversion is missed (it was tricky) and we go in half time 20-8.

HOPEHIV - Evs and DeanoAt half time we get to see Andre Vos again! He’s here to promote his new charity and the club’s charity for this season and the next, HOPEHIV. (Find out more about HOPEHIV on their website, www.hopehiv.org, or give them a call on freephone 0808 1000420. Registered Charity number 1079385)

Second half kicks off. We’re all sure that try before half time was just an aberration – a combination of Harlequins taking their foot off the gas and London Irish getting a couple of lucky bounces. I’m thinking “they always say don’t let your opponents score each side of half time”.

We obviously have a cunning plan for the second half, one which Irish will not be prepared for. We attempt to play the entire second half in our 22! If we do get any possession the rule is this has to be kicked away as soon as possible and not into open space.

We give away a soft penalty but the Irish kicker misses for once, so we breathe a sigh of relief. We replace Easter for Robshaw. At this point its still looking good and Irish defence is still looking a bit panicky.

We get a penalty for hands in the ruck, which Malone misses. A few moments later Irish miss another penalty, but about 15 minutes into the game we give away a penalty for offside which they duly kick to make it 20-11.

Shortly after the restart Irish finally string a good line out together. Chris Hala’ufia charges up the middle, Hodgson to Hewat then a miss pass to Delon Armitage then a foot race down the right wing and another try. Danny Care was convinced he’d gone over the dead ball line, but Dean Richards wasn’t interested. Duly converted its now 20-18 and Harlequins fans are nervous and Irish fans are now in full voice.

We get a line out on their 5-metre line, which we then lose. This leads to a line out near their 20-metre line.  We do a bit of pick and go (the pick part works fine but the go goes nowhere). With Danny Care somewhere in the previous ruck Chris Robshaw acts as scrum half and Irish intercept his telegraphed pass and Peter Hewat runs 60 metres to touch down under the posts. No problem with the conversion and we’re 20-25 down – what is going on?

Dean Richards mysteriously gives a penalty against Harlequins for something or other (offside?) when clearly we had three players to their one and their one was holding on.  The kick thumps against the right hand post and bounces left. The assistant referees pause before agreeing its over and we’re 20-28 down.

We’re running out of time and Irish are going through the play book of how to waste time. Kicks take an age to happen, scrums are reset and reset and reset…

However you can’t keep a good man down and Danny Care takes a huge miss pass and scores. Biggles converts and we’re 27-28!

With the countdown clock on zero we work hard to move the ball upfield. First we get to our 22, then our 10 metre then half way, then the Irish 10m. Unfortunately here under little pressure Tom Williams knocks on and the game is over!

Congratulations to Irish, commiserations to Harlequins! You’ll not convince me Irish won that game, Harlequins lost it and handed them the victory!

In the press conference afterwards someone said Chester Williams was in the stand and didn’t seem to be there with Andre Vos. No, I can’t get a good rumour out of that either!

Toby BoothToby Booth was first up.

He said that there had been too much emotion in Irish’s game in the first half and not enough consistency. He said they had to stop getting into the kind of position where they were 20-3 down. He agreed the first half try was a lucky turnover but with that momentum shifted. There was still plenty of belief and enthusiasm at half time, it just needed harnessing. With a small squad of 35 players, replacements who came on had to add value. Bob Casey coming on was a huge boost.

He was happy the game was very entertaining, and that it was played in a positive and pragmatic way by Irish.. He thought the ref had a great game and operated with empathy for the attacking team.

Dean RichardsThen Deano came on.

He thought we had a great first half. We played a poor territory game in the second half, made some poor decisions and let them into the game. He couldn’t see a reason why for the second time in a week we faded in the second half. For 30 minutes we couldn’t clear our lines and take the pressure off. It was irritating we gave away the try in the dying minutes of the first half, that gave them a sniff and they took it. He wasn’t critical of the ref, who got a good game out of the players.

Were the players fit enough? Yes – look at the last 10 minutes when we scored the try and so nearly got the ball down to drop goal territory!

As for other competitions, they’ll worry about them once Thursday is out the way!

Bookmark or share this story with:

Goto Thread: PreviousNext
Goto: Message ListNew TopicSearchLog In
Re: Harlquins 27-28 London Irish
Posted by: The Prof (IP Logged)
Date: 2008:09:28:21:48:49

Cheers DOK

Re: Harlquins 27-28 London Irish
Posted by: Jammy Git (IP Logged)
Date: 2008:09:28:22:15:48

Just to nitpick, DOK

"We get a line out on their 5-metre line, which we then lose. This leads to a line out near their 20-metre line. We do a bit of pick and go (the pick part works fine but the go goes nowhere). With Danny Care somewhere in the previous ruck Chris Robshaw acts as scrum half and Irish intercept his telegraphed pass and Peter Hewat runs 60 metres to touch down under the posts. No problem with the conversion and we’re 20-25 down – what is going on?"

What actually happened was...

We had slow ball, then managed a pick-and-go that actually got a lot of momentum. Unfortunately we then slowed it down while Danny stood there shouting at the "pod" forming in midfield. Hewat obviously knew what was going to happen and when the ball went to Robshaw, he telegraphed a ball inside and away Hewat went...

Re: Harlquins 27-28 London Irish
Posted by: DOK (IP Logged)
Date: 2008:09:28:22:23:35

I like your attention to detail. So which match will you be covering?

Re: Harlquins 27-28 London Irish
Posted by: Binky (IP Logged)
Date: 2008:09:29:04:31:24

Excellent report DOK. I don't suppose Deano can have a go at the Ref two weeks running.

What is Harry Hill doing standing on the pitch with Andre?

Re: Harlquins 27-28 London Irish
Posted by: Harleys Evil Step Mum (IP Logged)
Date: 2008:09:29:07:05:08

Countdown clock????.......we have a countdown clock?.....where?

Re: Harlquins 27-28 London Irish
Posted by: Quin Kong (IP Logged)
Date: 2008:09:29:07:23:03

A good read, shame about the result, thanks DOK.

Re: Harlquins 27-28 London Irish
Posted by: Harley Quin (IP Logged)
Date: 2008:09:29:11:47:52

Spot on DOK, thanks. If Deano thought we were fit enough, I can assure you it is not the universal view at the Club!

Re: Harlquins 27-28 London Irish
Posted by: DOK (IP Logged)
Date: 2008:09:29:11:54:56

Yes, but to be fair even if he thought they were all lazy tubs of lard, he isn't going to say that to the press! For what it's worth I think Irish 's replacement strategy was much better than ours (assuming we had one).

Re: Harlquins 27-28 London Irish
Posted by: PROUDasALWAYS (IP Logged)
Date: 2008:09:29:12:16:52

I don’t think I have ever been so annoyed about losing a game in my life. It wasn’t just losing a game – god knows we’ve had enough practice in the past! It was the manner of defeat. We handed them the game gift wrapped in nice paper with a pretty bow. At half time I chatted to a pal and said, “We’ve done enough haven’t we? We can’t lose this now can we?” No way" was his reply. Oh Jesus how wrong could he be! I suppose it was reasonable to assume we would continue in the second half to put the game beyond any doubt, although my own doubts had started to creep in before HT when Hewat got that try – the one we should have cleared before he got anywhere near it. We all know the rest. I normally go in the East stand bar to listen to that band regardless of our result – I couldn’t bring myself to go in there this time. I hope to god that’s the last time we stop playing at HT thinking we have already won the game. Though you have to credit Irish – they smelt blood and went after us with all they had. They must have sensed our attitude in that we thought we had done enough.

Re: Harlquins 27-28 London Irish
Posted by: BatQuin (IP Logged)
Date: 2008:09:29:12:41:13

HESM - the countdown clock is in the south-east corner. A countdown clock is compulsory for all GP games.

Re: Harlquins 27-28 London Irish
Posted by: Battering Ram Winger (IP Logged)
Date: 2008:09:29:12:46:10

Good report and as a fully paid up member of the MDS I feel this paragraph

Quote:
We get a penalty for hands in the ruck, which Malone misses. A few moments later Irish miss another penalty, but about 15 minutes into the game we give away a penalty for offside which they duly kick to make it 20-11.

sums up the real turning point. If we had gone 23-8 up, I think the sting may well have been drawn from LI's attack as we took everything they had and then coolly extended the lead again. As it was, they chipped away at the lead and we continued to lose our way until it was too late, at which point we threw the kitchen sink at them and had everyone around me wondering why the devil they hadn't managed this sort of play earlier in the half.

Re: Harlquins 27-28 London Irish
Posted by: Quin Like Flint (IP Logged)
Date: 2008:09:29:13:45:47

Quote:
Battering Ram Winger
If we had gone 23-8 up, I think the sting may well have been drawn from LI's attack as we took everything they had and then coolly extended the lead again. As it was, they chipped away at the lead and we continued to lose our way until it was too late, at which point we threw the kitchen sink at them and had everyone around me wondering why the devil they hadn't managed this sort of play earlier in the half.

or could it just be a random event that fits your pre-existing bias? Now, that bit in bold on the other hand...

Re: Harlquins 27-28 London Irish
Posted by: Boonie (IP Logged)
Date: 2008:09:29:13:57:36

One of the most disappointing losses I can remember. Some sublime play in the first half, and then a different team comes on for the second. Substitutions far too late to have any real effect. For half an hour, we did pretty much nothing. Despite the sunshine, a dark afternoon.

~~~~~~~
Harlequins.

Re: Harlquins 27-28 London Irish
Posted by: Battering Ram Winger (IP Logged)
Date: 2008:09:29:14:14:26

Quote:
Quin Like Flint
Quote:
Battering Ram Winger
If we had gone 23-8 up, I think the sting may well have been drawn from LI's attack as we took everything they had and then coolly extended the lead again. As it was, they chipped away at the lead and we continued to lose our way until it was too late, at which point we threw the kitchen sink at them and had everyone around me wondering why the devil they hadn't managed this sort of play earlier in the half.

or could it just be a random event that fits your pre-existing bias? Now, that bit in bold on the other hand...

Not really. I also blame Malone (and others, in fairness) for the endless load of utter drivel that came off his boot when we got the ball and were under the cosh. For a kicking fly half, he singularly fails to put any length on the ball when he does kick. I would have thought that if LI were at our throats, the logical thing to do would have been to get the ball out of our half so that if LI did want to attack, they'd have to chance their arm from deep rather than fielding tame little chips just outside the 22 and rushing up in numbers and with plenty of support.

Re: Harlquins 27-28 London Irish
Posted by: Jammy Git (IP Logged)
Date: 2008:09:29:14:50:17

Quote:
DOK
I like your attention to detail. So which match will you be covering?

smiling smiley

I considered it! But that bit stuck in my mind because it was so bloody frustrating at the time sad smiley

Re: Harlquins 27-28 London Irish
Posted by: Quin Like Flint (IP Logged)
Date: 2008:09:29:14:50:33

It just seems to be a bit of an obsession with some people (in fairness, not just you!). The question of why we started to just shovel the ball to him to kick every time doesn't seem to arise. Even when you acknowledge others kicked poorly somehow it's still his fault. This idea that fly halves can win games regardless of what everyone else is doing is, well - wrong.

Re: Harlquins 27-28 London Irish
Posted by: balpw2. (IP Logged)
Date: 2008:09:29:15:07:09

Can I just say that I really enjoyed that game. You guys were excellent in the first half and I thought we'd struggle but the try on half time gave me (and the team it seems) hope. Second half, was our turn.

Its a shame it wasn't a sell-out because that game deserved a full house. Its also a shame that we play in our white kit. Why was it okay for us to wear green for the friendly a few weeks ago but on Saturday we wear the boring white.

Re: Harlquins 27-28 London Irish
Posted by: Battering Ram Winger (IP Logged)
Date: 2008:09:29:15:57:13

I believe all complaints should be addressed to the GP and their ridiculous rules. How exactly your dark green kit with white flashes could ever be misten for our kit is quite beyond me. Expect to see us in our hideous away kit in w while.

Quote:
This idea that fly halves can win games regardless of what everyone else is doing is, well - wrong.

True, but a bad fly half can lose you a game by making poor decisions (such as continually kicking away decent ball into the North West area of the 22 rather than seeing what our backline might want to do with it with LI on the rack 20 minutes into the game).

Re: Harlquins 27-28 London Irish
Posted by: Quinten Poulsen (IP Logged)
Date: 2008:09:29:16:14:06

Robshaw's pass was a much poorer piece of play than Molly's missed penalty, and cost us 7 points, not 3. But not for one second would I lay any blame at Robshaw's door for us losing. I think to mention that missed pen as somehow resulting in what happened in the rest of the half is just daft.

______________________________
Gottle of geer, gottle of geer

Re: Harlquins 27-28 London Irish
Posted by: Quin Like Flint (IP Logged)
Date: 2008:09:29:16:22:48

Ah! Of course. Now we lost because 20-3 up after 25 mins represents a failure by Malone to have built a bigger lead. Does it really not occur to you to question this belief that only one player had any influence on the game?

Re: Harlquins 27-28 London Irish
Posted by: Props are not stupid (IP Logged)
Date: 2008:09:29:16:24:42

Hi, great read. It reflects exactly what I saw with my London Irish eyes. Would you like to have a read at the London Irish Match report in verse?

Re: Harlquins 27-28 London Irish
Posted by: DOK (IP Logged)
Date: 2008:09:29:21:07:36

Stone cold excellent report! Well done - I'm slightly green myself now!

Goto Thread: PreviousNext
Goto: Message ListLog In

Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.
We record all IP addresses on the Sportnetwork message boards which may be required by the authorities in case of defamatory or abusive comment. We seek to monitor the Message Boards at regular intervals. We do not associate Sportnetwork with any of the comments and do not take responsibility for any statements or opinions expressed on the Message Boards. If you have any cause for concern over any material posted here please let us know as soon as possible by e-mailing abuse@sportnetwork.net