Why We Should Welcome the Scorpions


South Wales Scorpions

By Andrew Collins
July 11 2014

A recent post on this message board from South Wales Scorpions’ fan Rogero got a surprisingly negative response from our regulars…

I’d like to start by stating that I am not a Rugby League fan. I’ve never been to a match live and have only watched snippets on TV. I don’t think I’ve ever seen a full match from start to finish. It’s not that I particularly loathe it in any way, it’s just that I’ve never taken the opportunity to give it a fair go. Or perhaps I’m just a stubborn union fans who discredits it because it’s not as ‘complex’ a game as Union (as in no scrums, line-outs, rucks or mauls).

All of this, however, is largely irrelevant to my argument.

The news that the Scorpions will be playing one game at Cardiff Arms Park strikes me as an excellent opportunity for the Cardiff Blues.

Thanks to the new artificial surface at CAP, we have literally no limit to how many activates – sports or commercial events – can be held at our venue. That poses huge potential from a revenue point of view, and it’s fantastic to see the Blues actively pursuing as many income revenues as possible. If the Scorpions don’t mind having 3rd dibs on the pitch after the Blues and RFC, then I would welcome them to make CAP their permanent home. The cost of hiring the venue, plus the revenue made from bars and food outlets makes their presence nothing but positive.

Secondly, I believe the Cardiff Blues should have a close relationship with the local League side. Lord knows how massive an influence Rugby League has had on union over the past decade – and in particular the past 5 years. A huge number of coaches, including Wales’ defence guru Shaun Edwards, have made the successful code switch to Union and have gone on to be extremely successful. Just this week, England’s former cross-code star Alan Tait has applied for the vacant Leeds Carnegie (union) job.

Likewise with players; yes of course there have been hits and misses, but why would you ever shut your doors when the next Jason Robinson could be playing League on your doorstep!

The opportunity to work closely with a Rugby League side can only be a good thing for the Blues; potential for join training sessions, coaches sharing ideas and collaborating on common themes such as defence and conditioning and the obvious possibility for players to try out at both sports and perhaps even arrange a loan or trial to see how they get on. With the Blues being the more affluent of the two, it’s fair to say that we could afford to ‘pinch’ any future union star from the Scorpions – a huge bonus for us! – while it works both ways, with many examples players who failed to make the cut in Union having gone on to be top level League players; see Elliot Kear as a casing point!

Finally there’s the potential for high profile joint advertising; Sale Sharks’ pre-season cross-code fixture against Salford Red Devils had drummed up real interest, although the match has since been postponed.

Though something of a gimmick, these sorts of fixtures offer both clubs a real opportunity to attract fans from outside the normal group – as I wrote previously, I’ve never really given League a chance, but if I liked what I saw and a joint season ticket were an option, well, who knows. They could convert me yet.

 

If you would like to read or comment on the original post from Rogero, follow this link http://www.rugbynetwork.net/boards/read/s170.htm?221,14817190

UPDATE: Many thanks to South Wales Scorpions, who sent us this interesting link by Twitter - bit.ly/1nkvNbo

If you'd like to buy tickets to see see the triple header event at cardiff Arms Park, featuring the South Wales Scorpions, following this link - bit.ly/1n4vXVP

Bookmark or share this story with:

Why We Should Welcome the Scorpions
Discussion started by theArmsPark.co.uk , 11/07/2014 11:47
theArmsPark.co.uk
11/07/2014 11:47
What do you think? You can have your say by posting below.
If you do not already have an account Click here to Register.

cardiffsteve
11/07/2014 12:02
Just to play Devil's advocate...

What if we do what harlequins did and get South Wales Scorpions to rebrand as.... Cardiff Blues?

They then use CAP through the summer (for a suitable fee...) whilst being more likely to get in people who watch Cardiff the rest of the year?

Unlikely. And ATTR might have an aneurysm.

But if we could work out a deal they can afford to allow them to base themselves there through the summer, I wouldnt be opposed.

Brings in money, hopefully we're keeping the bar takings too.

Realistically, closely aligning union and league sides has been tried before.... not sure what benefits there actually were at Quins etc.

gcblues
11/07/2014 12:09
Nice article, thank you.

I think we should embrace RL as a lot of their players also play RU so there is a cross over. I like RL so no problem them being there long term if they wished.

Rogero
11/07/2014 12:31
Thanks Andrew - both codes have much to offer each other. If you need convincing of how good a game it is watch the NZ v Eng semi final from last season's world cup semi final...

Thanks again...

Bluepragmatist
11/07/2014 12:50
Excellent article admn and aneurisms for attr et al apart, i would really welcome the south wales scorpions. in admitting that i like many am a rugby league fan, i am also a committed rugby union fan and totally support cardiff blues; there are huge benefits not only in the playing side of cross code
cooperation but as admin points out there are sizeable revenue advantages. so, lets welcome the scorpions playing a match on btsprortarmspark-i know i do-its a sprat to catch a mackeral of a future deal or possible rental income for our artificial pitch. i would say to detractors that any dosh for us is welcome.

ATTR
11/07/2014 13:45
If people read what I actually posted. I have no problem with RL or any other sport paying to use our facilities and putting money across our bars.

In fact this is EXACTLY one of the arguments some of us old CAP dinosaurs made about the move to the SdR. CAP could be used 365 days a year to earn us money. Now we have some intelligence in the marketing department and the dreadful Tina Tew is long gone (Sorry Ospreys!) we are realising that asset. The more people that want to pay to use CAP the better. t don't care whether I like their sport or whatever they do. Their money is good to us and can help us grow.

Let RL, American football, Tiddly winks etc all come and pay us MONEY. They are welcome. However, I do think people are allowed (can the thought police check this one) to say we don't like their sport. It would be a boring world if we all liked the same stuff.

PhillyBlu
13/07/2014 22:34
I stated earlier that the wider playing of league would help our backs play across the board. I play for Caerphilly, back in my youth days we regularly played against Penallta RFC. Penallta have both a union and league setup, and it attracts loads of kids etc. But the main thing I've noticed, is the over-all backs play of their union side at youth level, is a fair level higher than most other sides around. It's all good. League develops your flair players so long as you don't go down and try to copy a stereotypical English league approach

ATTR
13/07/2014 23:07
Sadly the RL style defence that Edwards and others have introduced has resulted in the Back play we see from Wales. Boring as hell. Bad league is not as bad a bad union, But good union is, for me far better.

Penallta have quality in their Youth set up. I think that may be more to the point.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2014:07:13:23:08:37 by ATTR.

sgorpioncaerdyddrob
14/07/2014 00:29
For me it is a win win for both sides, Scorps get to play a game at a higher profile stadium and hopefully gain wider attention across the capital and South Wales, opening themselves up to a wider audience, Cardiff RU get more money in the club through the new pitch for quality players etc.

I myself am involved with one of the local amateur rugby league clubs in Cardiff. Ex players of our side include Gethin Jenkins & Andy Powell, you may have heard of them?? So if anyone at the Blues would like to help us out with sponsorship, promotion, coaching, players or anything else I am all ears!!

ATTR
14/07/2014 08:53
Agreed, and good luck to you. As said in the other thread Union need to be shaken out of its current stupor.

ThatStrangeMan
21/07/2014 08:00
Excellent article. Well said.

ATTR
24/07/2014 16:09
There are three games altogether I understand. For anyone wanting to give it a try it seems quite good value. From a selfish point of view. It the RL guys deem it a success there is more chance of them paying us more cash in the future to repeat the idea. As I said before: "Win win".

sgorpioncaerdyddrob
24/07/2014 23:49
Gwendraeth Raiders v Valley Cougars in the Welsh Conference first up at 11, then South Wales v London U19 sides before the Championship 1 game. Think a few sides are coming along to watch and we'll take a few boys down who i'm sure will make themselves heard!

ATTR
25/07/2014 07:57
Listen to those tills rolling. There will be a few turning in their graves. But this is music to the FD's ears!

sgorpioncaerdyddrob
27/07/2014 21:15
Just like to say thank you to those at the club who helped manage today's proceedings, great weather, crowd and most importantly results on the pitch.

ATTR
27/07/2014 23:08
Nearly 500 there and good takings at the bar. Great stuff. I hope the league boys enjoyed the pitch.

Just shows we can be different and work together. Now there' a thought. Hmmmmmmmm.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2014:07:27:23:21:24 by ATTR.

Ian L
28/07/2014 10:17
A great afternoon at the CAP and thank you to the CAP staff for their excellent hospitality. As alluded to earlier in this thread both codes can work together.

ATTR
28/07/2014 11:07
Well said Ian.

oopnorth
29/07/2014 07:38
Hi. The Leeds rugby union side formed from a merger of the Old Headingley and Roundhay clubs, and called subsequently the Tykes and now Yorkshire Carnegie have shared the Leeds Rhinos facilities for about 16 years now, and still do. After some early resistance in both camps a working arrangement has settled down but it has not been all plain sailing and there are still some tensions. Good luck with the Scorpions, it sounds like on the whole you are looking at it in the right spirit.

ATTR
29/07/2014 07:59
The important thing is to welcome the difference. If you try and "convert" people you are doomed to failure. There was a mutual benefit to Sundays arrangement and that can, I'm sure, be repeated and a regular basis.

It's the same with the 7s game. We can work together well as long as the dafter "integration" nonsense is ignored.

On a different topic. What did the players think of the playing surface?

Bluepragmatist
29/07/2014 17:49
areed attr, the blues should try and get other sports as well like7s, league and nfl-more use means more dosh and other benefits for cardiff blues.
also hope that The Scorpions agree to return

ATTR
29/07/2014 19:12
Hospitality boxes can be rented for meetings etc as well. The club is getting its marketing in to gear. albeit from a low start point.

sgorpioncaerdyddrob
31/07/2014 08:11
May even be a permanent move...

ATTR
31/07/2014 10:11
I would welcome that.

theArmsPark.co.uk Admin
31/07/2014 12:11
Me too. Glad the day was successful. Best of luck with your season.

Admin of theArmsPark.co.uk,
Make Noise and You Will Be Heard!

http://v4admin.sportnetwork.net/upload/170/170_0_1264029860.jpg

ATTR
31/07/2014 12:50
££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££££

What's not to love.

Your Name: 
Subject: 
We record all IP addresses on the Sportnetwork message boards which may be required by the authorities in case of defamatory or abusive comment. We seek to monitor the Message Boards at regular intervals. We do not associate Sportnetwork with any of the comments and do not take responsibility for any statements or opinions expressed on the Message Boards. If you have any cause for concern over any material posted here please let us know as soon as possible by e-mailing abuse@sportnetwork.net